As the title suggests I have a bit of a guitar related dilemma. A while ago I was bought a Gretsch 5120 as a present. Whilst it is a nice looking guitar I struggle to play it as the neck is a bit too fat for me. The pickups are also pretty bland sounding as well. For the last few months I have been trying to decide what to do about it and have come up with the following options:
Keep the Gretsch but have the neck profiled, change the pups for BKPs (P90s), change the nut and change the pots. I would also like to turn it into a hardtail (is this even possible?). How much would having this work done roughly cost?
Sell the Gretsch and use the money to go towards buying a Highway 1 strat - change the pups for BKPs (HSS style), change the nut etc.
The other thing that bothers me about this is that the guitar was bought for me by my Dad - he phoned me from the states and asked me about what I thought of them. I did say don't buy it as the neck will be too big for me.
Really not sure what to do - any opinions?
Crumbs, that's a tough one (my Dad keeps buying us DVDs we already have - we daren't tell him. I keep saying "you need to check first, we've got hundreds like you have", but so far... :roll:)
So, have I got this right - you actually said "don't buy it"? If so, I'd be selling it and getting something I can call "special", then I can tell him "aw Dad, it was gorgeous, but like I warned you I just couldn't play it ... but just look at this beauty I've swapped it for..."
Or have we got some sort of "Dad thinking you need a proper guitar like his heroes played" thing going on here? That might complicate things further I guess... :lol:
If it had a better suited neck , is it your sort of geetar?
I think the only thing my old man ever bought me was a car. oh, and a bike when I was 9-10.
If either got sold, he would expect the money :P
Sell it, but get something silly on a new one, like specially engraved truss rod cover. If you're not happy with it, and want something new instead then it is best gone.
Maybe I'm misinterpreting your post, Ian, but I get the impression the Gretsch doesn't have much mojo for you - and still wouldn't, even if it had a more friendly neck, better pickups etc.
I'd sell it, but then I have a fairly cavalier attitude towards buying and selling guitars. :wink:
(Having said that, my parents have never quite forgiven me for selling the no-name Japanese LP copy they bought me when I was 16. "It's still a guitar isn't it, what's the difference?" )
I had a similar problem recently:
1) Gibson LP Standard, bought with money left me by my Granddad when he died
2) A Fender Strat, my second guitar, bought with saved up part-time job money when I was at school
Both guitars I never really bonded with after the initial 'wow'. The LP was heavy and very bright sounding, the Strat a bit dull. Both were sentimentally very valuable to me. I'd toyed with the idea of selling them for a long time, but never really got round to it.
Solution?
A trip to Vintage and Rare, two trade-ins and THAT Custom Shop Tele :D
I'd sell or part-ex the Gretsch for something you really want. Don't mod it - if you don't like it after the mods no-one else will if you try and sell it then...
Quote from: Twinfan on September 25, 2008, 01:18:17 PM
Both were sentimentally very valuable to me. I'd toyed with the idea of selling them for a long time, but never really got round to it.
Solution?
A trip to Vintage and Rare, two trade-ins and THAT Custom Shop Tele :D
I'm not quite seeing how you overcame the sentimental value aspect there Dave... other than extreme GAS! :P
:lol: nah - I get it Philly, a part-x means no filthy lucre changing hands over the old instruments, so there's more of a chance of "sentimental attachment transferral" ((C) 2008 AR, by the way :D).
I was actually going to suggest that earlier Ian - just up from V&R in Denmark St is my favourite shop, er, Regent Sounds, I think...
They're Gretsch stockists and mucho Fender, usually got some Highway 1s. The main man in there is obviously a strat-man, so perhaps that might be worth a visit...
Well, Ian - just tell your Dad that your house got broken into and that they stole your guitar - you got the money from the insurance and went to buy another one - however, the shop did not have any in stock and could not get any for weeks. Therefore, you did the next best thing and bought a Strat.
Basingstoke is a dodgy place so this will sound perfectly credible!!
Good luck
Mike
Quote from: AndyR on September 25, 2008, 01:46:12 PM
:lol: nah - I get it Philly, a part-x means no filthy lucre changing hands over the old instruments, so there's more of a chance of "sentimental attachment transferral" ((C) 2008 AR, by the way :D).
Hmmm. I think the threads of sentiment might be stretched to breaking point.... :?
I had the same sort of dilemma with an amp a while ago. Dad bought me it for my birthday but I never really got on with it, all it did was cleans and nasty distortion (not the good kind either!) and I wanted to play rock so it wasnt ideal. I tried to get it to work for me for about 2 years but it never happened so sold it and got something more suitable. I think he was a bit annoyed/upset but I wasted so much time and money trying to get it to work for me and it never did, as soon as I got the Laney instead everything was fine :) So I'd say if it doesnt work for you then dont bother trying to make it unless there are some quick/easy fixes that may help..
Quote from: Philly Q on September 25, 2008, 02:16:45 PM
Quote from: AndyR on September 25, 2008, 01:46:12 PM
:lol: nah - I get it Philly, a part-x means no filthy lucre changing hands over the old instruments, so there's more of a chance of "sentimental attachment transferral" ((C) 2008 AR, by the way :D).
Hmmm. I think the threads of sentiment might be stretched to breaking point.... :?
:) sentiment takes the form of threads? you learn something new every day
Quote from: gwEm on September 25, 2008, 02:30:49 PM
Quote from: Philly Q on September 25, 2008, 02:16:45 PM
Quote from: AndyR on September 25, 2008, 01:46:12 PM
:lol: nah - I get it Philly, a part-x means no filthy lucre changing hands over the old instruments, so there's more of a chance of "sentimental attachment transferral" ((C) 2008 AR, by the way :D).
Hmmm. I think the threads of sentiment might be stretched to breaking point.... :?
:) sentiment takes the form of threads? you learn something new every day
Well, we say "sentimental attachment", so I picture threads. I have a visual imagination. :oops: :P
Quote from: AndyR on September 25, 2008, 01:46:12 PM
:lol: nah - I get it Philly, a part-x means no filthy lucre changing hands over the old instruments, so there's more of a chance of "sentimental attachment transferral" ((C) 2008 AR, by the way :D).
That's it exactly. No dirty cash involved, the guitars were 'upgraded' to the Tele. Their legend lives on in a complete keeper :D
Quote from: Twinfan on September 25, 2008, 02:52:56 PM
Quote from: AndyR on September 25, 2008, 01:46:12 PM
:lol: nah - I get it Philly, a part-x means no filthy lucre changing hands over the old instruments, so there's more of a chance of "sentimental attachment transferral" ((C) 2008 AR, by the way :D).
That's it exactly. No dirty cash involved, the guitars were 'upgraded' to the Tele. Their legend lives on in a complete keeper :D
+1 Dave - like your thinking. I always find trades get you less money though.
Philly - as usual you are right. The Gretsch simply has no mojo for me. I have also known to be cavalier with guitars in the past so think it is only the 'sentimental' value that is making me keep it at the moment.
Mikeluke - I have been through so many variations of how I could explain the Gretsch not being there. The one I keep coming back to is the simple truth (although some parts of Basingstoke can be dodgy!)
Finally - thanks to all for the responses so far, it has helped me make my mind up. A tough decision but I do need to be fair to the Gretsch.
I got great trade-in prices at V&R, like REALLY great. Take the Gretsch in there, and see what you can come out with ;)
Maybe it's just my parents, but if the replacement guitar was vaguely the right colour, they'd probably not notice.
Quote from: Twinfan on September 25, 2008, 06:37:40 PM
I got great trade-in prices at V&R, like REALLY great. Take the Gretsch in there, and see what you can come out with ;)
I don't want to start giving myself ideas, but..... as much as you'd have got by selling them privately (or, let's say, on commission)?
Quote from: Twinfan on September 25, 2008, 06:37:40 PM
I got great trade-in prices at V&R, like REALLY great. Take the Gretsch in there, and see what you can come out with ;)
Trouble is Dave I would't get a price that allowed me to get a guitar that I wanted. I don't have lot of spare cash around at the mo (just bought a new tele) hence the need to go private sale (unless V&R offered £400.00ish - and I seriously don't think they would!)
Edit - by tele I mean television. Not tele. :o
I got £425 for my Strat and £875 for my Les Paul. That's as good as I would have got selling them privately :o
I think there was some wiggle room on the price of the Tele, but even so I was impressed.
Quote from: mikeluke on September 25, 2008, 02:06:01 PM
Well, Ian - just tell your Dad that your house got broken into and that they stole your guitar - you got the money from the insurance and went to buy another one - however, the shop did not have any in stock and could not get any for weeks. Therefore, you did the next best thing and bought a Strat.
Basingstoke is a dodgy place so this will sound perfectly credible!!
Good luck
Mike
Uh why not just try being honest. I dont know maybe talk to him and ask him what he thinks about you trading it in for something else. Buying a Strat is not usually a good Idea
Quote from: mikey5 on September 25, 2008, 09:53:58 PM
Uh why not just try being honest. I dont know maybe talk to him and ask him what he thinks about you trading it in for something else. Buying a Strat is not usually a good Idea
Yep - said that in my response. Also not sure why 'buying a strat isn't usually a good idea'. I get the feeling you're not a fan of them - am I correct?
Quote from: Twinfan on September 25, 2008, 07:58:09 PM
I got £425 for my Strat and £875 for my Les Paul. That's as good as I would have got selling them privately :o
I think there was some wiggle room on the price of the Tele, but even so I was impressed.
That's actually not a bad deal but as you say a some of it was probably due to the price of the tele. Not sure how much I would get in trade if I was looking at a guitar of roughly similar value!
Quote from: Ian Price on September 25, 2008, 10:51:29 PM
Quote from: Twinfan on September 25, 2008, 07:58:09 PM
I got £425 for my Strat and £875 for my Les Paul. That's as good as I would have got selling them privately :o
I think there was some wiggle room on the price of the Tele, but even so I was impressed.
That's actually not a bad deal but as you say a some of it was probably due to the price of the tele. Not sure how much I would get in trade if I was looking at a guitar of roughly similar value!
Not a bad deal? I'd say it's a pretty extraordinary deal! I've never been offered anywhere
near that in P/X (and not just because I'm rubbish at haggling).
Okay Philly - I'm obviously not very good at spotting a good deal!
I didn't even have to haggle. Over the phone I was offered £400 and £800 against the Tele. When I got down there, I'd been quoted £100 too cheap on the Tele so they upped my trade-in valules so that the 'price to change' was the same.
You gotta love V&R ;)
Quote from: Twinfan on September 28, 2008, 10:03:56 AM
I didn't even have to haggle
but.. but..
you ALWAYS have to haggle. Even on guitar picks! :D
do you not find its no fun otherwise?
V&R does seem very cosy, I was tempted to put my name down for notice of any Firebirds coming in.
Quote from: Twinfan on September 28, 2008, 10:03:56 AM
I didn't even have to haggle. Over the phone I was offered £400 and £800 against the Tele. When I got down there, I'd been quoted £100 too cheap on the Tele so they upped my trade-in valules so that the 'price to change' was the same.
You gotta love V&R ;)
I think I might just schlep my whole guitar collection down there and see what I come out with! :lol:
Quote from: Philly Q on September 28, 2008, 10:11:17 AM
Quote from: Twinfan on September 28, 2008, 10:03:56 AM
I didn't even have to haggle. Over the phone I was offered £400 and £800 against the Tele. When I got down there, I'd been quoted £100 too cheap on the Tele so they upped my trade-in valules so that the 'price to change' was the same.
You gotta love V&R ;)
I think I might just schlep my whole guitar collection down there and see what I come out with! :lol:
:lol:
There's a nice '52 Blackguard Tele there Phil ;)
Quote from: Twinfan on September 28, 2008, 11:04:11 AM
There's a nice '52 Blackguard Tele there Phil ;)
9.5" radius and they might have a sale....
I jest. But it's all too easy to imagine it happening one day.
The last few responses on this thread aren't really helping me! Just been on V&R's website and they have this:
http://www.vintageandrareguitars.co.uk/web/our-catalogue/Fender/Electric-Guitars/item/3719
and this:
http://www.vintageandrareguitars.co.uk/web/our-catalogue/Fender/Electric-Guitars/item/3704
I really want them both. I might need to do a Philly and trade a few!
The Nocasters have a HUUUUUUUUUGE neck. You'll need to try before you buy.
Take the Gretsch and some cash, and have a play ;)
Quote from: Ian Price on September 28, 2008, 05:03:58 PM
I really want them both. I might need to do a Philly and trade a few!
That's doing a Dave. Doing a Phil is buy first, then quickly start taking photos and writing eBay ads before the credit card bill comes through. :wink:
I think you should go for the blackguard. And I really like this one:
http://www.vintageandrareguitars.co.uk/web/our-catalogue/Fender/Electric-Guitars/item/3706 (http://www.vintageandrareguitars.co.uk/web/our-catalogue/Fender/Electric-Guitars/item/3706)
I'm sure it's a nice guitar to play but for some reason sunburst teles do nothing for me. This is very strange as sunburst strats are my favourite.
Come on, Ian - in you are gonna go for it then REALLY go for it!!
http://www.vintageandrareguitars.co.uk/web/our-catalogue/Fender/Electric-Guitars/item/3436
:lol:
Hate 3 tone burst... And what is the joy of buying a '58 Strat NOT beaten up??? :?
Quote from: Ian Price on September 28, 2008, 06:57:59 PM
I'm sure it's a nice guitar to play but for some reason sunburst teles do nothing for me.
I totally agree! Actually, I'm not keen on sunburst anything :oops:
I go through phases with sunbursts, most of the time I like them but generally I prefer solid colours on Strats (he says, having just bought two Strat bodies with transparent finishes...).
But I like that '58 Strat a lot. As for the Tele, I've never seen a sunburst with a black plate like that - but since nobody likes it maybe it'll still be there when I decide to buy it in a year's time! :wink:
Quote from: mikeluke on September 28, 2008, 08:15:15 PM
Come on, Ian - in you are gonna go for it then REALLY go for it!!
http://www.vintageandrareguitars.co.uk/web/our-catalogue/Fender/Electric-Guitars/item/3436
:lol:
That is awesome. It's a shame there's not a close up of the neck - the grain on the headstock looks stunning.
Quote from: Twinfan on September 28, 2008, 05:15:48 PM
The Nocasters have a HUUUUUUUUUGE neck. You'll need to try before you buy.
Take the Gretsch and some cash, and have a play ;)
Cheers Dave - as you know I really don't like big necks! The V neck on my '57 reissue strat is my perfect neck profile. I would love to have a tele with the same profile.
That 58 has a particularly nice three-tone sunburst, doesn't it?... (much like the one on my JV Squier... that I removed x years ago :roll:).
I understand that three-tone on maple-boards are quite rare as well, only some in 59 (and 58 obviously!).
Looks like you'd need to trade in more than your Gretsch though! - don't suppose you've got a spare kidney or small child, have you? :wink:
The way this thread is going Ian, I reckon that the "sane", or "grown-up", advice is "Do not got to V&R, and stop looking at their website!!!"
Quote from: AndyR on September 29, 2008, 08:38:37 AM
The way this thread is going Ian, I reckon that the "sane", or "grown-up", advice is "Do not got to V&R, and stop looking at their website!!!"
Cheers Andy - I nearly considered a visit to V&R, you're matureness has helped hold me back (for a while at least!)
sell everything its the fecking recession of our lifetimes!!! :lol: