I have been looking at semi's 335 style and have come across Eastman guitars which look really nice but not had a chance to try one. Has anyone here had a chance to play any of there guitars or have any opinion on them.
http://www.eastmanguitars.com/models/thinline.html]http://www.eastmanguitars.com/models/thinline.html]http://www.eastmanguitars.com/models/thinline.html (http://www.eastmanguitars.com/models/thinline.html)
Not many places stock them, but there is one in derby which I could go try, but it quite a long round trip for me, so I thought i'd see what the opinion here was on them.
this is a pic of the one in Derby, I think it looks stunning
http://www.fouldsmusic.co.uk/image.php?object_type=detailed&image_id=1459&window=popup (http://www.fouldsmusic.co.uk/image.php?object_type=detailed&image_id=1459&window=popup)
Philly Q I think it's you that keeps having es 339 gas, they do a 3 different body sizes 14" 15" and 16". I expect the 14" is similar is size the 339 also just a little bit cheaper.
opps put the links as emails
I haven't played one yet but I've seen LOTS of them in the flesh and they look very nice. They have a slightly worn look about them that's attractive. The thing to bear in mind is that they are made in China, although the quality is supposed to be top notch.
You need to speak to Fourth Feline who posts in here. He has done some great research on 335's and settled on a Tanglewood with MQ's in the B/N. Have a look back to one of his threads on a search.
There are a lot of builders who are currently making some good quality 335 guitars
Tanglewood
Vintage
Indie
Peerless
Adam Black
Yamaha
ect
All need a p/u swap and a maybe pots and switches changed depending on whats in them to start with.
Quote from: Johnny Mac on March 08, 2009, 07:24:16 AM
You need to speak to Fourth Feline who posts in here. He has done some great research on 335's and settled on a Tanglewood with MQ's in the B/N. Have a look back to one of his threads on a search.
There are a lot of builders who are currently making some good quality 335 guitars
Tanglewood
Vintage
Indie
Peerless
Adam Black
Yamaha
ect
All need a p/u swap and a maybe pots and switches changed depending on whats in them to start with.
Cheers Johnny ! :)
I have not tried or seen all of the above, but my impressions so far , are :
1) Based on direct experience :Tanglewood : being the cheapest to buy, yet the machine heads, wiring, pots and pickups are fine as they were really. To be specific - the TH502 I bought had Grover Machine heads from the factory, full size 500K volume and tone pots and sheilded wire as standard. I even ended up putting the 'stock' pickups back in - as they seemed fine. Even better news for more recent buyers , is that ( according their very helpfull staff who I e:mailed for more info ) my pickups where from the ceramic P/U era - whereas production has moved to Alnico pickups . It set up really nicely - and plays really slinky. The downside ? probably that mine was basswood laminate body and mahoghany neck - so the bass strings do not sound as bright and articulate with Alnico II / weaker pickups as my ( maple ) 'Vintage' Archtop. I got mine 'shop soiled' - but only about £140. The most affordable and solid option ended up being the Tanglewood.
(Bear in mind I always swap the plastic nut off of my guitars for something more resonant- and Tanglewood / Vintage have plastic nuts ).
Vintage : Better choice of woods, and more authentic if you want something that
looks directly like a Gibson copy. The action set up rattle free easily as well - the downsides being that the machine heads were very light weight 'Wilkinson'
copies of pressed metal Grovers and a bit weedy. They held tune well, but I wanted the weight / more solid shaft / front headstock washers of real solid cast Grovers. The pickups where only just o.k. - but probably a bit bright/ stiff sounding for an archtop. The Volume and tone pots where minatures - but at least had the right value ( i.e. 500k ). Set up wise and generally, I could have gigged this straight out of the delivery box.
Aria : I tried one of these in a shop, and the neck action on it was awful. No amount of lowering the bridge and adjusting the trussrod could get the action anywhere near the neck. Yes, I probaly got a bad one - but it did seem to suggest that ( unlike Tanglewood / Vintage ) in the same price brackets -
where was the quality control between factory and distributor ?
Buy the Vintage if you probably want to upgrade bits / re-wire and change pickups but end up with a nice end result ( I.e. deliberate copy of an unaffordable brand ) - due to the neck / frets / body being very good from an assembly / luthier standpoint. I could get mine for £250 - with the intention of upgrading - and as I like the ES-175 look , did just that.
For 'ready to play off the shelf' - I was very tempted by
Peerless, but had something like the pickup(s) been not quite to my liking - there would be no upgrade budget left. They have had the sense to use proper Grovers, bone nuts, selected woods though.
2) Based on specifications / reputation but NOT direct experienceEastman : Seemed to be going for the best product quality - and the appearance of a guitar worth much more . I have not seen / handled one myself - but those helpfull chaps at Foulds of Derby seem to know their product, especially when it comes to Jazz orientated guitars and accessories. If I look at photos of their ( Eastman ) Archtops, they ( as has been mentioned by Gingataff ) look less glossy / plasticky than Vintage / Tanglewood / Aria / Hagstrom and even Peerless. I would go for Eastman if spending more serious ££££, but probably be torn between them and the Peerless in the realm of Archtops.
My
Vintage guitar turned out great, but I bought,
knowing that it was going to be an affordable base for deliberate modification. All it had to do ( for me ) was to play VERY slinky when fitted with 12s, or 13 top Flatwound strings ; be well assembled ( including neat binding e.t.c ) - and look the part of a Gibson Archtop. The idea being to knowingly spend £250 - then copy / better something that Gibson retail at about £2,500.
Yamaha : Had I had oodles more cash, the SA2200 is seemingly legendary. The problem for me ( during my 335 hunting days ) - being that the price ( if we are talking 335- a - likes ) puts it in the 'Why not get a good Gibson second hand and retain a higher re-sale value later' category.
So :
For 335 types , try the
Tanglewood first. After you set the nut / action up to your liking, It could be a complete solution without mods.
Vintage for naughty impersonations of Gibson, but potentially budget for pickups, pots and and tuners e.t.c.
The other ' higher ticket' versions ( i.e. Yamaha / Eastman / Peerless ) if you see one you like so much you feel easy about paying the extra ££ and not modifying it.
Happy hunting ! :)
Quote from: JustBecos on March 07, 2009, 08:12:27 PM
Philly Q I think it's you that keeps having es 339 gas, they do a 3 different body sizes 14" 15" and 16". I expect the 14" is similar is size the 339 also just a little bit cheaper.
You're right, it is me :lol: .
They look very nice indeed - and making essentially the same guitar in a choice of body sizes is a great idea. The T184MX would be the one for me, although it sounds like it's constructed more like a CS-336 than an ES-339.
I wonder what the pickups are like? I know Kent Armstrong has a reputation for making excellent "jazz" pickups.