Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum

Forum Ringside => Pickups => Topic started by: Acatalepsy on March 19, 2011, 07:42:37 AM

Title: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: Acatalepsy on March 19, 2011, 07:42:37 AM
Hey guys,

I'm new here, so I'd just like to say I'm exited to be here- seems like this is a really great community :) I'm looking to change the bridge pickup in my Schecter c-7 blackjack (mahogany body, set neck, rosewood fretboard, Seymour Duncan JB in bridge) basically, with my current rig, I go straight in to an ENGL Savage 120 or Thunder 50 and I find that the tone is a bit dull and muddy. I find that my other guitar, a ltd sc607b with emg 707s at 18V sounds much better, even though it has the same woods. Basically, the qualities I am looking for are clarity when I play complex chords and a fairly high output since I don't like too much dynamics for the style of music I play (progressive black metal, a bit like this- Surreale | Haeiresis ) I rarely palm mute, so I'm not terribly interested in how 'djenty' a pickup is.

thanks for your help!

Additional info- I use lots of mids in my tone, so anything that has a scooped voicing is out.
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: Slartibartfarst42 on March 19, 2011, 09:21:06 AM
Until you mentioned all the mids I was thinking Miracle Man but instead I'd guess at either a Painkiller or Aftermath. I've only tried a Painkiller once and it wasn't for me but I think you might like it. I've never tried an aftermath myself but from what I've read I think it may suit you. Hopefully somebody with more experience of both will comment.
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: Telerocker on March 19, 2011, 10:45:47 AM
Sounds like Aftermath.
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: Acatalepsy on March 21, 2011, 12:30:46 PM
Cheers guys! Any more thoughts?
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: darkbluemurder on March 21, 2011, 01:05:02 PM
Until you mentioned all the mids I was thinking Miracle Man

My thoughts exactly! But I would not call the MM scooped. To me it is clear in the mids, i.e. it does not have a mid spike.

To the OP: I believe you have a critical combination in the mids with the Engl amps and the Seymour Duncan SH-4, so even if you use a lot of mids on your amp I would not necessarily add a pickup with a mid overload.

but instead I'd guess at either a Painkiller or Aftermath. I've only tried a Painkiller once and it wasn't for me but I think you might like it. I've never tried an aftermath myself but from what I've read I think it may suit you. Hopefully somebody with more experience of both will comment.

I have not tried either but out of those two I would rather suggest the Aftermath. I would also look at the Nailbomb.

Cheers Stephan

Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: llJasonll on March 21, 2011, 04:04:46 PM
Finally, I can add input to a tone question!  :D

Well I play through a Savage 120, and I have Painkillers in my custom Mahogany body, maple neck, rosewood fretboard; and I absolutely adore my tone from my guitar.  I would highly recommend the Painkiller.

It looks like we go after the same kind of sound.  I like a lot of cut, and clarity, but I need some sizzle, at times.  If you play technical, with any amount of harmony and lead work; I think you will love this pickup.  Open chords have that perfect clarity and cut; and you get endless, shimmering sustain.

This pickup isn’t for everyone, but I think you might like it a lot.  When you push the tubes on the Savage, and combine this pickup into the mix, it is a beautiful thing!

The painkiller is the only BK that I own, but I have a Ceramic Warpig on the way (for another guitar); and I will be ordering a Ceramic Nailbomb HSS set with Sinners (for yet, another guitar); so if should have something to compare to in a couple weeks.

If you have any questions about the Painkiller, or how I set my tone on the Savage let me know and I will be more than happy to offer my input.  8)

Cheers!
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: Acatalepsy on March 21, 2011, 04:21:12 PM
Finally, I can add input to a tone question!  :D

Well I play through a Savage 120, and I have Painkillers in my custom Mahogany body, maple neck, rosewood fretboard; and I absolutely adore my tone from my guitar.  I would highly recommend the Painkiller.

It looks like we go after the same kind of sound.  I like a lot of cut, and clarity, but I need some sizzle, at times.  If you play technical, with any amount of harmony and lead work; I think you will love this pickup.  Open chords have that perfect clarity and cut; and you get endless, shimmering sustain.

This pickup isn’t for everyone, but I think you might like it a lot.  When you push the tubes on the Savage, and combine this pickup into the mix, it is a beautiful thing!

The painkiller is the only BK that I own, but I have a Ceramic Warpig on the way (for another guitar); and I will be ordering a Ceramic Nailbomb HSS set with Sinners (for yet, another guitar); so if should have something to compare to in a couple weeks.

If you have any questions about the Painkiller, or how I set my tone on the Savage let me know and I will be more than happy to offer my input.  8)

Cheers!


Thanks for your input! I'd be curious to hear how you set it for sure, I use:

high gain channel
lead boost in
gain slightly less than 4/10 gain
bass 5/10
mid 6/10
treble 6/10
presence slightly under 5/10
voicing: rough
bass boost: off

as I said in my initial post, I like the way my other guitar pairs with it, but I can't use that  since I keep it in another tuning for another band. What kind of music do you play?
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: ericsabbath on March 21, 2011, 04:26:06 PM
nailbomb
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: llJasonll on March 21, 2011, 05:17:02 PM
For rhythm:
High gain channel
Lead boost off (will definitely change the tone for more cut)
Gain: about 12 – 1 o clock
Lead Gain about 2-3 o clock
Bass: about 12 – 1 o clock
Mid: about 11 o clock, sometimes 2-3 o clock (depending on mood)
Treble: about 1 o clock
Red Master
Red Presence: 12 o clock with the depth boost pressed in.
Voicing: Smooth
Countour: Not pressed in (to give the mid spike)

Lead:
I turn off bypass on my Maxon OD-808 for lead stuff
High gain channel
Lead boost on
Gain: about 12 – 1 o clock
Lead Gain about 2-3 o clock
Bass: about 12 – 1 o clock
Mid: about 11 o clock, sometimes 2-3 o clock (depending on mood)
Treble: about 1 o clock
Green Master
Green Presence 2-3 o clock with the depth boost pressed in.
Voicing: rough, sometimes smooth depending on mood
Countour: Not pressed in (to give the mid spike)

I play mainly metal.  My bands songs are pretty all over the place.  These pickups and amp seem to do the trick for me; I feel that I can get quite a versitile tone with these pickups.
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: Madsakre on March 21, 2011, 07:46:27 PM
i tried the Cold sweat in a friends custom guitar(librium) and i fell totally in love. The sound of that pickup is close to perfection. It covers black metal terribly well(dissection style) and does death metal quite well too. it has that percussive edge to it if you tweak it.

well.. next step is to have a Cold sweat equipped guitar for me. DAMN I LOVE THAT PICKUP!
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: ratspeak on March 22, 2011, 06:55:38 PM
I had the same problem with the JB7. Don't know what the SD guys were on when they said it sounds best in mahogany guitars with rosewood boards, but I want some.

I replaced my JB7 in the same guitar with an Aftermath, but I think it might not be hot enough for what you want. I'd say Nailbomb (ceramic or alnico) or a Ceramic Warpig. I don't think the neck-warpig would sound good in that guitar though.
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: Excruciator on March 22, 2011, 10:15:03 PM
I'm only fleetingly acquainted with your amp, so I can't give any really solid input, but I know the rest of your gear pretty much inside out through personal experience, and I also play a lot of bm/progressive bm, from earlier Ulver and Emperor through to Blut Aus Nord and Deathspell Omega.

My current favourite guitar for playing this kinda stuff is an ESP/LTD M307, which is pretty much the same as your guitar, although neck through rather than set neck and 25.5".  I have that loaded with a Painkiller in the bridge; don't let the "djent" descriptions put you off, it's perfect for raw and savage bm tones as well. It's got enough output for any application you could possibly need, and clarity is not an issue, even on the low B. I'm not sure I'd call Haeiresis' tone particularly raw or savage though, so it's your call. The Paikiller can certainly cope with the more refined bm tones, but I can't help but think you'd be better off with one of the contemporary AlNiCo's if you wanted to nail that tone exactly - I've heard some very convincing, more refined bm tones played through a Rebel Yell, fwiw, and the Nailbomb is an obvious contender too.

Edit: Don't let the JB7 put you off BKP Alnico's; the Duncan 7 string pickups are bad even compared to their own 6 string namesakes, especially the JB7.
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: dheim on March 24, 2011, 02:36:16 PM
uhm... for that kind of tones i'd reccomend cold sweats, but what you need, in the end, is an articulate and not so hot pickup, possibly tight and more or less bright. so ceramic (but also alnico) nailbomb, painkiller, aftermath (never tried one - this is pure second hand knowledge!), rebel yell could work quite well. anyway when i think about "new" black metal cold sweats are my weapon of choice! ;)
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: ratspeak on March 24, 2011, 09:57:39 PM
Edit: Don't let the JB7 put you off BKP Alnico's; the Duncan 7 string pickups are bad even compared to their own 6 string namesakes, especially the JB7.

QFT, I had a JB6 in my ESP for quite a while and there was nothing wrong with the pickup. The JB7 is nothing like the JB6, and Tim really knows how to get the best out of Alnico.
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: Acatalepsy on March 25, 2011, 05:21:06 AM
Thanks for your thoughts guys, I emailed Tim about this and he said the Aftermath would probably be the best pickup for me. I think I'm going to go for that  8)
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: Madsakre on March 25, 2011, 10:27:30 AM
AND a cold sweat :D

Seriously dude. That pickup is $%&#ing amazing!
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: Acatalepsy on March 25, 2011, 01:49:41 PM
As a neck pickup?
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: Madsakre on March 25, 2011, 01:53:05 PM
as a bridge bro :P never tried the neck version
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: Slartibartfarst42 on March 25, 2011, 04:44:07 PM
I think that if Tim has said the Aftermath is your best option in the bridge then that's what you should go for but the Cold Sweat is certainly an excellent neck option and I do speak from personal experience.
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: Acatalepsy on March 26, 2011, 10:08:45 PM
For rhythm:
High gain channel
Lead boost off (will definitely change the tone for more cut)
Gain: about 12 – 1 o clock
Lead Gain about 2-3 o clock
Bass: about 12 – 1 o clock
Mid: about 11 o clock, sometimes 2-3 o clock (depending on mood)
Treble: about 1 o clock
Red Master
Red Presence: 12 o clock with the depth boost pressed in.
Voicing: Smooth
Countour: Not pressed in (to give the mid spike)

Lead:
I turn off bypass on my Maxon OD-808 for lead stuff
High gain channel
Lead boost on
Gain: about 12 – 1 o clock
Lead Gain about 2-3 o clock
Bass: about 12 – 1 o clock
Mid: about 11 o clock, sometimes 2-3 o clock (depending on mood)
Treble: about 1 o clock
Green Master
Green Presence 2-3 o clock with the depth boost pressed in.
Voicing: rough, sometimes smooth depending on mood
Countour: Not pressed in (to give the mid spike)

I play mainly metal.  My bands songs are pretty all over the place.  These pickups and amp seem to do the trick for me; I feel that I can get quite a versitile tone with these pickups.

Hey mate, I tried your settings at band practise tonight and although I still kept the eq I usually use, I've found that the smooth voicing works a lot better for black metal in a band context! Thanks for your advice, my tone is much clearer now! :D
Title: Re: Recommend a pickup for progressive bm
Post by: llJasonll on March 27, 2011, 02:29:23 AM
Good, I'm glad to hear!!  :D

That's cool that you are going to go for the Aftermath, I am currently in the midst of a custom project and I have been eyeing the AM for the bridge!