Hi,
Am about to acquire a Tokai LP Special (mahogany body & neck, rosewood board, and will be fitted with a Bigsby)and am already thinking of upgrading the existing Gibson P90s to BKs.
I play mainly clean/light overdrive through Fender amps, getting my dirt mainly from pedals, but want to be able to handle heavier tones as well as 70s Santana/McLaughlin/Gilmour/Beck type fuzzy leads.
Which of the above two pickups would you recommend as being the most appropriate?
Thanks
Hi, your thread caught my eye because I'm a big fan of LP Juniors and Specials, but I'm afraid I haven't tried any of the new BKP P-90 range.
The description of the Half Note does seem to emphasise the pure, natural tone and that it's mainly for jazz and other clean styles - nothing to suggest it's suited to anything heavier. Whereas the Nantucket seems to be designed more for the full range of classic P-90 tones.
If I was buying for my own guitar, I would certainly like to try the Nantucket bridge. On an LP Special, I'd also be interested in the Blue (rather than Half) Note as a neck pickup for a softer, sweeter kind of tone. But I do like a lot of contrast between neck and bridge, more than most people seem to.
So, I reckon Nantuckets are probably going to suit you better - but hopefully someone who's actually tried them will chime in.
Not too familiar with the P90 stuff, but seems like Nantuckret should be good.
Nantuckets for classic late fifties, early sixties G....n-style tones. Good for any blues, rock, even hardrock.