Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum

At The Back => Time Out => Topic started by: donovan.x on February 18, 2006, 09:24:28 AM

Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: donovan.x on February 18, 2006, 09:24:28 AM
Following a thread started by Ratrod about Sunn Mustangs it got me wndering..How often in the guitar world do you get value for money?
I used to have a Sunn and will have again in a few days and yeah it will probably need a few new bits done to it but hell, most of us are doing that with top end guitars! The only guitar that I loved as much as my Sunn is my SG standard, it rocks but I was lucky, as we all know Gibson can be a bit hit and miss.
So have you got any storys of guitars that justify the hefty tag or any storys on a genuine bargain..a diamond in the rough.
I have had an extensive history in low end ,mid range and top end guitars
and so far in my mind the budget boys are leading.
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: Elliot on February 18, 2006, 10:41:00 AM
Well as i have said before - in 1984 I did a play off between a Tokai strat, a Squier JV and an American Fender and the JV won, Tokai came second and the Fender a poor 3rd.  Yet I note that Soho Soundhouse are selling  'warehouse find' 82 strats for megabucks on the basis that they are genuine fenders and therefore quality.
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: big steve on February 18, 2006, 11:20:18 AM
i got a richwood strat for £150 (because it had a ding in it, pales into insignificane next to the ones i've put in it though :lol: ) added a few bits and bobs, tuners, electronics etc, quality plank now.
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: Ratrod on February 18, 2006, 12:15:50 PM
I usually go for something affordable and then pimp it.
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: Peterku on February 18, 2006, 01:48:29 PM
I have two electrics: an ash Strat-copy modded to hell (I bought it for its body and neck, now only the wood, the back plate, the jack plate and the nut are stock), and a custom-built Artist (see my avatar). Both have the best components I could find for their application. Neither project was cheap but now both guitars are exactly like the ideal image in my head. However, while the Artist has an exclusive feel (you won't go to work every day with a Maybach ;)) and I play it only when I need that - heavenly - sound, I use my Strat for rehearsals and practice as a versatile workhorse guitar, and I don't mind scratches on it (it only has a thin natural satin finish anyway). Both guitars are equally useful to me.
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: Dakine on February 18, 2006, 03:59:14 PM
LOL
ALL my purchases have been (IMO) bargains! Cept maybe my Les Paul.

I got my "natural" finish Jackson Soloist SL4 (jap. thru-neck) for $480 (think 277 quid). It needed a re-finish really as it was chipped in places so got it covered on insurance and Ron Pace Luthier currently has it. So it will be like new for that price.

My first Ernie Ball Axis was $500 (with two small chips on front, no whammy bar and no case, bout 289 quid). I ordered a whammy bar for $12 and will get a case free (read on lol). So all in (and it's my FAVE axe) it cost 295 quid.

Second Ernie Ball Axis (hardtail this time) I got from a guy that won it for "Best Guitarist" at the Boston Ermengenza and did'nt want it (he plays a Lucille) so sold it to me for $500 new in case hangtags and all!!!! Also, with it's paintjob, it's one of only 3 ever made! Hardcase has a small ding and the shipping was insured so UPS is gonna pay for a new case (eventually) which will house the first Ernie Ball :)

Lastlty, the one that got away. Well not really, the one I should NEVER have sold (I have travelled/worked round the world as a Professional Diver then ROV Supervisor for over 15 years so did'nt have the chance to play at the time). Was a first edition Warwick Streamer Bass. Exotic unfinished hardwood, straightthrough neck, bees wax finish, active pickups, gold hardware, strings still bright from new, 280 quid if memory serves, from rich kid who bought it as first Bass and could'nt/did'nt want to play.

Bargains ARE out there. Just gotta keep an eye out. Also, my dad ALWAYS told/taught my "Money Talks". Cash (rather than credit etc.) is a POWERFUL incentive/bargaining tool.

Sorry for long post but ya asked LOL

Nick
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: Searcher on February 18, 2006, 05:54:12 PM
In my experience you get what you pay for, unless you're really lucky (or unlucky).

My favourite guitars have been damn expensive--$6000 Martin, $6000 Tele, current $3000 Zion custom. The '73 SG and '78 Strat I had were good too, but required some doing up. None of my other guitars have really come close to the expensive ones, especially in the acoustic arena.  Even those ridiculously over-priced Fender relics sound and feel better than the average Strat or Tele.

I think the only exception is when you build a guitar from parts; then you can get it a lot more cheaply than if it had been mass-produced or custom-made for you.
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: sambo on February 19, 2006, 12:52:06 PM
you've had guitars worth $6000...!!?!???!
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: Searcher on February 19, 2006, 06:51:28 PM
Quote from: sambo
you've had guitars worth $6000...!!?!???!


Heh. Yeah.

<name dropping>I bought the Tele from Mark Evans, the old bass player from ACDC, back in Sydney, Australia. I felt paranoid about playing it out and so I sold it. The person I sold it to then sold it to George Harrison shortly before he died. He was also was selling an acoustic guitar for $225,000 AUD. That was a bit much.</name dropping>
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: sambo on February 19, 2006, 07:22:57 PM
dear god.... you.... you.... you RICH PERSON!
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: hobleguitars on February 19, 2006, 07:36:36 PM
Sambo, get a paper-round!
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: sambo on February 19, 2006, 07:46:47 PM
for your information, i had a paper round, but it was 7 days a week, £2 a day.... what a great rate that was! damn why ever did i quit that... i could have been at $6000 in no time! blast!
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: hobleguitars on February 19, 2006, 07:53:09 PM
That's slacker-talk. Earn your keep!
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: sambo on February 19, 2006, 07:55:06 PM
not a chance at that kind of disgraceful pay.... i thought it was a joke to be honest.... are you telling me that you would work for that?

or are you just deliberately trying to incrimnate me as a lazy bar-steward!?!  :evil:
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: Gochaz on February 19, 2006, 08:12:36 PM
In fact, Hobleguitars stubbonly refuses to get a job, and he has never had one, either.

Back on topic, I'd rather buy a beastly guitar on a budget.
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: sambo on February 19, 2006, 08:16:43 PM
ahah! trifled by your own companion.... i feel for you hob-ley my friend... i feel for you....

oh and i think your inbox is full as well...

p.s clear your inbox/sign in again i've enquired about a hoble!

p.s #2 clear again its stuck in my outbox grrrr
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: hobleguitars on February 19, 2006, 09:27:25 PM
Ho ho ho. I vote beast.
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: Muttley on February 19, 2006, 09:38:13 PM
I had to vote Beast, as my JEM is so far ahead of any other guitar I've tried playability-wise and sound-wise.  That set me about about £1600 though.

On the other hand, I also love my Gibson SG as a sling around, gigging guitar, adn that cost me about £300 second hand.

Muttley
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: sambo on February 19, 2006, 09:40:08 PM
JEM's man.... they're soooo lush....

P.S #3 and again hoble lol
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: bubchronic on February 21, 2006, 03:18:58 PM
My first guitar ( 1984 ) was an SG copy. It was made by Avon under Rose Morris. Wasn't a bad guitar, but one day the treble pickup wasn't working, so I took the pickup apart, covers off etc, and what a suprise when I found there was only a single coil behind the cover, the case was half empty,ha ha, what a con. Wondered why it used to be noisy and squeal when it was working.

p.s I still voted budget. If the neck is good, wood is good, feels good to play, stick some decent pickups in and you are sorted.
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: lepersmeesa on February 21, 2006, 03:55:41 PM
I consider all my guitars bargains.

I got my ESP MV 300 for £250 when it was worth £900.
I got my Ibanez RGT 2020 for £800 when it was worth £1500.
I got my Ibanez Rg 7321 for £250 when it was worth £350.

And got my Engl......well for an undisclosed fee.....for now.

All of them being brand new as well.
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: _tom_ on February 21, 2006, 05:01:30 PM
Quote from: lepersmeesa
I consider all my guitars bargains.

I got my ESP MV 300 for £250 when it was worth £900.
I got my Ibanez RGT 2020 for £800 when it was worth £1500.
I got my Ibanez Rg 7321 for £250 when it was worth £350.

And got my Engl......well for an undisclosed fee.....for now.

All of them being brand new as well.


You've got soo lucky  :o !! Bargains or what
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: monkeywalker on February 21, 2006, 08:08:23 PM
i generally go for budget guitars, about £600 and then replace the pots and so on.when youve finished you can quite easily end up with something to rival an american model of twice the price.
Title: Is it worth it!!!! (guitar costs, not life :D)
Post by: sambo on February 21, 2006, 08:11:04 PM
you say pots and so on... but what else do you do? i want to upgrade anything thats possibly upgradable on my axe but im not sure whats actualyl worth replacing... i mean what makes a noticeable difference thats worth upgrading?