I have read from Nolly that the Warpig is "a way more versatile pickup than it gets credit for" (scroll down here https://forum.bareknucklepickups.co.uk/index.php?topic=37385.0 (https://forum.bareknucklepickups.co.uk/index.php?topic=37385.0)). Other than the chugs, plus jazz and fusion as mentioned in that thread, what other applications does this pickup have? And how do you dial in a tone for those cases? If someone were to say "the warpig is great for reggae!" for example, I'd love to also know what amp, cab/IR, and pedals you're running.
Bonus question: does anyone know if the Warpig is similar to the Kiesel Thorium? That's what I actually own. They look similar at least in their spec sheets.
I'd say you're overthinking this by several degrees. Ultimately, any pickup will do any application, and we're only ever discussing the last 15% or 10% difference, generally. Bear in mind that for most genres, the amp is what's dictating what's possible and the overall tone, and the pickup is just fine tweaking.
The Warpig is full-bodied and has incredibly rich, thick mids with a sweet top end. Obviously it's been designed to sound like a beast for metal, but those characteristics will translate well into almost any setting unless you're going for the most scooped, thin tone you can manage. I finally got my Warpig installed relatively recently and was expecting a hot, thick mess, but it surprised me. The clarity and richness are so much fun, and the overriding characteristic is it just sounds *huge*.
So through a 5150, yeah, that's going to be absolutely crushing. Through a plexi: massive, rich power chords2, and sure, it's a touch more compressed than a PAF but who's going to notice other than the player? Through a clean amp, again, very full and rich sounding, and yes, it's going to hit the front end a bit harder but that can be accounted for.
So yeah, I don't see why you couldn't use a Warpig for reggae - but then I don't see why you couldn't use any pickup for reggae, as long as you've got a cleanish amp. What you play and how you play it are much more important, and the gear you use can always be made to work around that.