Poll
Question:
What set?
Option 1: BKP-90
votes: 9
Option 2: BKP-91
votes: 2
Option 3: BKP-92
votes: 0
Option 4: A mix of the above (ex: 90/92 set)
votes: 2
Option 5: Someone else entirely (Fralin, Lollar, Duncan etc)
votes: 1
Hi all, new guy with an SG Classic here.
Been contemplating upgrading the pickups in my SG Classic for a while now. It sounds okay as it is but there's room for improvement, I'm sure. I'm a BIG fan of Townshend and his sound, especially the 'Tommy-era' sound ('68-'70) like you're probably familiar with from Woodstock and Live at Leeds.
So I'm thinking, I know I want to swap the pickups eventually but with Who? I'm pretty familiar with all the different P-90 makers, Fralin and Lollar and of course Bare Knuckle Pickups, which I always come back to. Uh, this is dragging on a bit... so I'll just get to my rig:
- '06 SG Classic (stock) strung with D'Addario 11s
- Fender Blues Jr for amplification
That's really it. I have an old DS-1 somewhere but I don't like it anyway. So what do you guys think will best get me to the Live at Leeds kinda sound? BKP-90s? 91s? 92s? Or another brand entirely? Any other recommendations?
Oh yeah, here's my SG. Towser's the name.
Click here, lol (http://s160.photobucket.com/albums/t198/Every_Mn_photos/Guitar%20stuff/?action=view¤t=IMG_0892-1.jpg)
I also have an '04 MIM Strat (black, rosewood neck) and a Bigsby-equipped 05 Ibanez Artcore (red), if it means anything...
Nice gee- tar ;)
I've voted for the regular P-90 set. I have some in a LP Special double cut (close enough to an SG) and they rock a fat one. Clear, thick and articulate.
Get an unpotted set and you'll be in tone heaven :D
Quote from: TwinfanNice gee- tar ;)
I've voted for the regular P-90 set. I have some in a LP Special double cut (close enough to an SG) and they rock a fat one. Clear, thick and articulate.
Get an unpotted set and you'll be in tone heaven :D
Thanks.
So not having them potted will allow for some microphonic feedback, right? I don't gig so I wouldn't see that as something to get concerned over much. How 'bout you?
I don't gig that particular guitar. but even with high-ish gain it's not a problem. The extra sparkle from unpotted pickups works for me, espcially in a P-90 that's traditionally very bass heavy. Plus they don't have metal covers and are less prone to feedback issues.
Quote from: TwinfanI don't gig that particular guitar. but even with high-ish gain it's not a problem. The extra sparkle from unpotted pickups works for me, espcially in a P-90 that's traditionally very bass heavy. Plus they don't have metal covers and are less prone to feedback issues.
What do you think about pairing one of those in the neck with a 91 or 92 in the bridge position?
I have a 91/92 set which have a bit more mids (more like a trebly humbucker) which I like, but I think for the "Townshend Saw/Windmill" kinda thing you should go for a less output, more open sound.
Quote from: hunterbut I think for the "Townshend Saw/Windmill" kinda thing you should go for a less output, more open sound.
I'd like to get a Fuzz Face or something to compliment the rest of my set-up... I know the Univox is a big part of his sound from that era, but I haven't seen one on eBay at less than 300 bucks.
A P-90 neck and P-91 bridge might be a nice combo, but the as Hunter says you're straying away from the Live at Leeds tone then...
Exactly what I wanted to say, but forgot to say: 90s it should be.
Hotter ones might smoothen out things too much.
I'm interested in the opinions here, because I have a PT signature SG which will probably be BKP'd eventually. Not really going for a Townshend sound but I'd like to stick with P-90-types.
I don't know what the specs of the stock Gibson P-90s are, but I find the neck and bridge pickups sound too similar because they're very close together. I was thinking BKP-90 neck and BKP-91 bridge, perhaps.
Slight hijack: which would be best for a Leslie West tone, d'you think?
Leslie West = a Mississippi Queen ;)
Seriously though, in P-90 form you'll want a P-91 I'd guess. On the phone to Tim when I was discussing unpotted P-90s he said that the MQ is somewhere between a P-90 and a P-91.
Thanks Dave, that was what I was guessing (tentatively).
So it's a 90/91 set for me then. After I get the Emerald/Mule set for my V, Crawlers for my LP, Warpig for my SG-X....
So far the consensus for me is a BKP-90 set, then?
Quote from: Every_MnSo far the consensus for me is a BKP-90 set, then?
We agree, you have our blessing to go ahead and order them :D
Quote from: hunterQuote from: Every_MnSo far the consensus for me is a BKP-90 set, then?
We agree, you have our blessing to go ahead and order them :D
Now I just need some money. It's surprisingly hard for a 16 year-old to find a job in So Cal. I've looked but I guess I didn't get out fast enough because they're all taken or too out-of-the-way.
I notice the BKP site sells them and lists them with GBP, anyone know a good US distributor for them? Specifically in the Southwest?
www.musictoyz.com is pretty good don't know if they have all the bk models, though. you can subtract the value added tax which is 17% off for us americans, so you'll only come out a little cheaper buying from musictoyz if you buy straight from tim you can get him to wind it special :lol:
I don't think there'd be a need for any custom wound anything...
People who voted 'mix', could you please explain your choice further?
So that's it, then, the BKP-90s?