I certainly wouldn't argue with Tim or Doug, and definitely not with BOTH of them!! If they say Nailbombs, you want Nailbombs.
I would personally get plain black covers for that, but then I'm rather conservative when it comes to guitar looks (not counting my current guitar, which doesn't count because I only got it "from a mate because it was cheap"!).
Roo
(PS, it's your decision, none of us can *really* make it for you).