i agree with MDV, on the main topic and on the sheep/cat argument.
there's no way to gather cats unless it's exactly what they intend to do themselves. and this points clearly that cats are way more clever than sheeps, men and dogs who loose their time trying to gather them.
AND, going back to topic, general tone guidelines are easy to put down, with a bit of experience and some clear idea on woods... it's much more difficult to extract useful informations from single experiences, because guitars are all different and - most of all - individual tastes are often COMPLETELY different.
for example Twinfan could say that his experience with the Mules has been less than satisfying... mine has been much better and in general Mules seem to be very popular among LesPaul players (but not just among them)... who will you believe?
i bought an LTD EC1000 (with EMG 81/60) on the web after having tried a Duncan equipped model... when i extracted it from its case i saw it's flawless satin black finish, its sexy shape and i thought WHOOOO! :)
i started playing it unplugged, had the first acoustic and tactile impressions and thought WHOOOAA! :D
then i amplified it and heard the dry, thin and screechy EMG 81 i thought URGHH! :x
i could describe the painfully sudden change of facial expression just using some sexually related example but, being a gentleman, i won't (lately there's been some talk about guys looking like girls and... ok. stop it.) (no personal experience, anyway)
so i changed the little black bar-steward in a week or so with a much MUCH better EMG 85 (just for information, Painkillers are coming to kick their active asses out of it... :))
i know some idiot who would have sold it after a couple of days without even trying a pickup change... i actually bought one of my favourite axes from one of those...
but the point is that a vast majority of players praise the 81s and 81 equipped ESP/LTDs as the ULTIMATE metal gear.
so who's right?