There are also some vintage / modern vintage designs I'd consider. Although tone shaping options may be limited they can still offer anything from dynamic clean/crunch to spectacularly dirty and raunchy overdrives. Add a clean booster for increasing gain or solos. Three usable sizes spring to mind:
1) +/- 5W with 8 inch speaker: although the clean headroom is very limited these will crunch up and distort at living room levels which is nice for recording. At full whack they sound huge when recorded properly. Vintage: Fender Champ (tweed/blackface/silverface), Gibson Skylark / Modern: Epiphone Valve Junior (the head version is better), TAD tweed Champ kit, Ibanez Valbee
2) 5-10W with 10-12 inch speaker: a larger speaker and more powerful power amp will result in larger overall tone and a bit more clean headroom. These are giggable if you play distorted most/all off the time. Vintage: Fender Princeton (tweed/blackface/silverface), VOX AC10, Gibson GA9 / Modern: Laney LC15, Bad Cat MiniCat, Cornford Harlequin, Hiwatt 7W combo, TAD Blackface Princeton kit, Cornell Romany
3) 15W with 12 inch speaker: this format offers enough (semi-)clean headroom and volume for small to medium size gigs. For home recording they might be too loud in overdrive but offer nice clean sounds. However they are excellent for recording in a studio that will take some noise. Vintage: Fender Deluxe (especially the tweed version), VOX AC15, Marshall 18W combo, Marshall Studio 15, Gibson GA40-GA20 / Modern: VOX AC15CC1, Fender Pro or Blues Junior, Fender Deluxe reissue, TAD Marshall 18W kit, TAD tweed Deluxe kit, Cornell Rambler
I tested most but not all of the amps mentioned above, I mentioned some as examples off the format.
I myself prefer the 15W format because I can rehearse and gig them. I truly love the sound from my late 50's Gibson GA20T which is very similar to a tweed Fender Deluxe. These are available as DIY kits through TAD and others. The clean with bite on these is excellent and the overdrive very grungy but not out of control (no flabby bass or piercing higs). I also like the new VOX AC15CC1 although it's cleaner sounds are a bit less focused. The valve trem however is a nice bonus. In the lower price range the Epiphone Valve Junior and Laney LC15 (with master volume so plenty of overdrive at low levels) are pretty good IMO.
Hope this rambling helps a bit :oops: