So, I'm assuming that the original design was a 25.5" scale?
The Holydiver certainly still works nicely in a shorter scale length guitar, but it is going to shift you a little bit darker than your original combination would have been.
If you like that darker vibe, then there's no huge reason to not stick with the Holydiver, but, if you wanted to make a small shift brighter in the pickups, to adjust for the warmer instrument, the Black Dog or Peacemaker would both be worth a look.