I went for the wonder that is the immortal Pearly Gates for the sheer fact that it always was, and still is, the Reverends main weapon of choice.
Lucille has had too many incarnations, Page plays too many guitars (No1, No2, No3, Telecasters, that doubleneck etc!), and EVH now doesn't use the frankenstrat......which was a shed in my opinion anyway. Yes EVH made it sound amazing, but would you cherish it????
What about Mr Youngs SG?