Username: Password:

Poll

Which is the best route?

Tech 21 Power Engine 60 + Electro Harmonix Blackfinger (approx. £390)
2 (40%)
Peavey KB-4 + Electro Harmonix Blackfinger (approx. £370)
0 (0%)
Samson Servo 200 and 2 X Samson RS15 speakers + Electro Harmonix Blackfinger (approx. £420)
0 (0%)
Atomic 50w 1 X 12 (approx. £490)
3 (60%)

Total Members Voted: 5

Voting closed: May 06, 2008, 12:04:05 AM

Author Topic: Amp Options  (Read 4175 times)

nfe

  • Welterweight
  • ****
  • Posts: 2510
Amp Options
« Reply #15 on: May 29, 2008, 12:18:03 PM »
Quote from: hamfist
Quote from: Doadman

The shop didn't have the PA gear in stock that I was looking at but I tried a Mackie SRM450 Active PA speaker. At £379 it is somewhat over budget and was only a 12" speaker where I'd been told a 15" works best but it was certainly noticeably better than the Power Engine.


 I have a few things to now consider.

1) Should I go with a power amp and passive speakers or active speakers?
2)In a budget of £300 - £350 should I get two speakers to go stereo or simply get a better quality single speaker and play in mono, as I would have done with the Power Engine?
3) As I know absolutely nothing about PA speakers, other than being able to confirm that the Mackie was good and built like a tank; what are the best ones to look at in that price range?

As always, your help is greatly appreciated


The SRM450 is definately a 15" speaker BTW. The SRM350 has a 12".



No. The 450 is a 12" the 250 is a 10". Definately.

If you decide to look at ANY Mackie gear, I can't recommend highly enough that you buy second hand and at least 4-5 years old when they were still being manufactured in Italy. The newer ones break every two minutes and their warranty returns procedure is an absolute joke.

Before the recent takeover when I was still working there, Soundcontrol as a company had, in stock, 46 Mackie SWA1501, all broken and around a hundred each of SRM350s and 450s, all broken. These were all still in stock because Mackie avoid returns at all costs and most of them had been sitting in stock (almost all belonging to customers who had other gear out on load) for months waiting for Mackie to collect. Obviously all of these were warranty repairs so all of them were less than a year old.

hamfist

  • Welterweight
  • ****
  • Posts: 1341
Amp Options
« Reply #16 on: May 29, 2008, 02:18:06 PM »
Quote from: nfe
Quote from: hamfist

The SRM450 is definately a 15" speaker BTW. The SRM350 has a 12".



No. The 450 is a 12" the 250 is a 10". Definately.

If you decide to look at ANY Mackie gear, I can't recommend highly enough that you buy second hand and at least 4-5 years old when they were still being manufactured in Italy. The newer ones break every two minutes and their warranty returns procedure is an absolute joke.

Before the recent takeover when I was still working there, Soundcontrol as a company had, in stock, 46 Mackie SWA1501, all broken and around a hundred each of SRM350s and 450s, all broken. These were all still in stock because Mackie avoid returns at all costs and most of them had been sitting in stock (almost all belonging to customers who had other gear out on load) for months waiting for Mackie to collect. Obviously all of these were warranty repairs so all of them were less than a year old.


You right, me wrong, me sorry. 450 = 12",   350 = 10"

Interesting to hear about all those returns. I have owned, and know friends with 350's and 450's (all within the last 4-5 years). Most of these have led a hard life in PA's. None have had any problems with theirs.   One factor may be that there really are a lot of these out there, in use. So even a small return %, would seem like a lot of units being returned.

Doadman

  • Guest
Amp Options
« Reply #17 on: May 29, 2008, 05:17:20 PM »
Certainly sound wise the Mackie was impressive. It had none of the tweeter dominance that some people complain of and the overall sound was rich and full. However, partly due to price and partly due to the issues that have been raised I'm looking seriously at a couple of alternatives.

The frontrunner at the moment seems to be a Yamaha MSR400 as everyone I speak to tells me it's good, though I'm also looking at a Carlsbro Gamma 15/400A; DB Technologies Opera Live 402 and the usual Behringer items. Unfortunately the nearest place that seems to stock them all is a 3 hour drive away so I can't demo them any time soon. Nevertheless, any advice is always welcome.