• Welcome to Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum.
 

boosting with a Boss PQ-3B 'Bass Parametric Equalizer'

Started by gwEm, May 01, 2008, 11:53:41 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

gwEm

I frequently mention how much I like my modified Boss GE-7. I keep coming back to this pedal as a booster.

Anyway, I knew all along a good parametric EQ would be a better choice. TO reminded me of this on the forum, and so I brought one. Single band parametric EQs are available as pedals, but multiband ones are rare, and tend to be rack units. Spec-wise the Boss PQ-3B would seem to be about the best compromise between features and user friendliness, and I was lucky enough to find one on ebay.

Affect on tone when inserted and switched off
There is a small but noticeable bass loss. High end is hardly changed. Unusual for a Boss pedal.

Affect on tone when switched on and controls in a neutral position
Slight volume increase. Marginally more pronounced "presence" range. Negligible increase in noise.

In use compared to standard GE-7
Overall the pedal is alot less noisy than a standard GE-7, I also believe its a bit more transparent. +18dB of clean boost is useful, and its a nice clean boost too!

I expected the 'Low' and 'High' controls to be shelved EQs, in fact they are band EQs. It would be *much* nicer to have these as shelves in my opinion.

Setting the controls to extreme settings increases the noise of course, but its less than a standard Boss GE-7. The 'Q' of the filters is a little bit nasty - I put this down to cheap capacitors used. I wanted to set the controls for a largeish bass roll off, a light treble roll off and a mid boost, with the output level maxed out. Thats how I use my GE-7.

The bass roll off is easy enough to dialin - the parametric EQ makes it easy to do in a good way. Using with a bass rather than electric guitar I found I could dial in some cool tones using this control too.

Treble roll off was not quite so satisfying, the slightly nasty Q and the band rather than shelved nature of this control meant the results were a little unpredictable with electric guitar. With a bass this control was more usable, but occasionally ice-picky. Treble was nice through my JMP50 than the Lead 12.

I found using the mid control for getting a modern 'scooped' sound on bass and electric was very easy and satisfactory. That was fun for a while, but I wanted to boost the mids in general. Boosting the mids did not give nice or predictable results. Even with a minimal boost it sounded very wah like.

So overall I'd say this would be a nice pedal for a modern metal bassist or guitarist. It sounded better than an standard GE-7 and was lower noise etc etc. Cool scooped sounds, great control over bass frequencies.

For those looking for a more classic boosted mid sounds I wasn't so keen, it ended up sounding artifical however I dialled it in.

Modding thoughts
Obviously the PQ-3B sucked life out of the tone compared to my modded GE-7, and was noiser. I also noted the Q of the filters was a bit nasty. Of course modding could address these issues quite easily with new op-amps and capacitors.

Opening the pedal revealed a relatively simple circuit with 6 inline opamps. Perhaps Monte Allums chip adapters could be used. The capacitors were easily accessible.

Would modding make mid boosts more usable? I think so, but it would need a lot of experimentation which I don't have time for. A great mod would be to change the bass and treble controls to be shelves.

Will I trade my modded GE-7 for a standard PQ-3B
No

Will I trade my modded GE-7 for a modded PQ-3B
Don't know - but I have my doubts. Both pedals have their uses.

How would I design a parametric EQ pedal for guitar?
Low - shelf EQ, one knob controls cutoff frequency
High - shelf EQ, one knob controls cutoff frequency
Mid - full parametric EQ with cutoff frequency, Q and boost
Level - one knob controlling boost with a wide range bias towards boost. -12 to +24dB maybe

I think a single band parametric EQ with nice bass shelf and overall level control would have its uses too.

Relative ratings
Standard GE-7 7/10
Standard PQ-3B 8/10
Modded GE-7 9/10
Quote from: AndyRyou wouldn't use the meat knife on crusty bread but, equally, the serrated knife and straight edge knife aren't going to go through raw meat as quickly

Will

Just been reading back a bit, these things confuse me. Does a parametric EQ have a selectable frequency peak / trough then?

gwEm

Quote from: Will on August 14, 2008, 11:51:38 AM
Just been reading back a bit, these things confuse me. Does a parametric EQ have a selectable frequency peak / trough then?

yes, you can select a frequency, and how much you want to boost/cut it by.

more fancy parametrics allow you to select the size of the range around the center frequency you adjust.

as you can tell, i thought it was a really good idea to use as a booster, since it would give quite alot of flexibility. in fact, the design of the pedal could have been a better... i mean its good for a boss, but not in the same class as a boutique or modded pedal. in fact, i've not really used since this initial test.

i lated found dimebag used a rack parametic eq - which one would have thought would be of high quality, and it shows my idea worked for someone. i don't want the hassle of carrying round a rack with me though. yesterday i was really impressed by the design of the EQ on the RC booster i got from twinfan. didn't have the facility to do a mid boost per se though, but it shows the benefits of good design.

i'd love the chance to design a pedal

edit: quite tempted by your V, by the way
Quote from: AndyRyou wouldn't use the meat knife on crusty bread but, equally, the serrated knife and straight edge knife aren't going to go through raw meat as quickly

Will

Sounds tempting, I prefer a lead boost at about 2.5K, can you dial it in as the number value, or just turning a knob until it sounds right?
Did you mod it in the end? and is it recomendable?
Sorry for the questions, but I tried reading stuff about them, and my brain got in a knot :?

gwEm

Quote from: Will on August 14, 2008, 12:25:46 PM
Sounds tempting, I prefer a lead boost at about 2.5K, can you dial it in as the number value, or just turning a knob until it sounds right?
Did you mod it in the end? and is it recomendable?
Sorry for the questions, but I tried reading stuff about them, and my brain got in a knot :?

i haven't had the time to mod it unfortunately. the EQ has three bands with different ranges (i forget exactly what now) so, yeah - you do a bit of both, there are numbers to set it roughly and then you can tweak it by ear.

is it recommendable... mmm - hard to say. its abit rare, and you pay slight collectors prices. In my case I paid £78.30. I would say its on the cusp of recommendability. i'd probably sell mine if you were interested, or if you pay the postage i'd loan it to you.

artec do a 'cheap as chips' single band parametric (the boss is 3 bands) which you can get for 30 quid on ebay. i never tried it, but it might be cool to experiment with.
Quote from: AndyRyou wouldn't use the meat knife on crusty bread but, equally, the serrated knife and straight edge knife aren't going to go through raw meat as quickly