the RR tribute Marshalls do sound good, but like the old non-master volume Marshalls, it's still gonna have to be cranked somewhat to get plenty of gain (the RR amp doesn't have a MV either).
it's a pretty crude 'mod' actually and a bit of a strange one since Marshall were already making their 2204/2203 amps at the time when they modded Randy's white 1959 head. all they've done is to cascade the normal and brilliant channels into each other, but you can't argue with the results - it sounds great. I'd personally have liked to see a (defeatable) master volume on the amp so you can balance the preamp and poweramp gain without having to crank it.
that said, it's a niche amp that does the job well - if only they'd got the cab right :roll:
The "one wire mod" as it's known is a bit crude as you've mentioned, I've found it impossible to dial in a good tone using this mod which makes me think marshall might have changed a few values, eg the coupling caps on the first valve to 2200pf on both sides or something similar, I've designed a few mods with an extra gain stage infront of the first valve stage and I've also tried turning the cathode follower into a gain stage so you have a plate driven tonestack which is a nice way to do it, the lee jackson way of adding a gainstage after the CF stage is also well thought of but I've not tried this yet.
Still think the 2203 is the best way to get that extra gain but retain the crunch/dynamics of the Marshall sound though, and a stock plexi is great with a pedal pushing it anyway so why mod it?
The schematic I have shows it to simply be the 'one wire mod' as you say. no mods, just a straight up 1959 head except the bright channel doesn't have the 2200pF coupling cap, it's a 22nF cap on both sides.
I've tried a plate-driven tonestack recently and didn't like it at all - harsh and honky. I added a DC-coupled CF and it smoothed out the tone considerably, much nicer.
I like a gain stage after the tonestack, but not setup for quite as much gain as the Lee Jackson stuff. The way I've done it is to have an AC-coupled CF after the tonestack to drive the effects send, then have a 'recovery' stage (return). I add a small amount of gain for more 'hair', but you could go crazy and drive the piss out of the recovery gain stage for more filth :lol:
I agree that the 2203 is the best way to get more gain too - it's my fave Marshall.