I dont really see how you can say 'dont consider 42 or 42.5mm' when you have no idea how big his fingers are.
He did actually state that he was finding an SG a bit narrow, and awkward, and that would have been 43mm, so I asusmed that it would have been silly to go any smaller
That extra 0.2mm between the strings makes all the difference, huh?
Yes. To me it does. Why make life difficult for oneself if you don't need to ?
Anyway, sweet guitar Bradock PI. As you've found, if you play a few, you can find some really nice Epi LP's.