Unless you want to spend a fortune I'd just go for CTS pots and orange drop caps with some cloth covered wire just for the aesthetics. The difference will be noticeable in how the pots taper and the quality of the rolled off tone. Also, as the caps are only cheap you could could get a few and try different values.
I got paper oil caps for my prewired pickguard and tele control plate and to be honest I think orange drops would have been just as good, to my ear anyway....