• Welcome to Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum.
 

Same clip - Marshall VM / Axe through VHT / Axe direct - what's your verdict?

Started by hunter, May 23, 2009, 09:40:35 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

hunter


Allrighty, I did similar clips over the past months/years, different guitars but all mahogany with vintage/hot BKPs.

So here is the same-ish clip, once Marshall VM through Cab/SM57, once Axe FX through VHT2502 and SM57, once Axe direct.

What do you think of the 3? Can you guess which is which?
Tweaker's Paradise - Player's nightmare.

Ian Price

I'm really not sure. I'm rubbish at stuff like this but would go for:

A - AxeFX > VHT
B- AxeFX direct
C - VM

Probably completely wrong! They all sound good to me though, and I listened to them all through the internal speakers of my little laptop!
I think I hate being indecisive.

the prince of shred

im not sure as im not really experianced to tell but A sounds best but a little 'fake?' computerized i guess?? C sounds good but weaker but also warmer..? n b just sounds weak and muffled with the midds n highs muffled ....

hunter


Allright, the solution is ... (don't scroll down if you wanna check later)



...



...




...



...


The solution is:







A: Axe direct
B: Marshall
C: Axe through VHT
Tweaker's Paradise - Player's nightmare.


Twinfan

The lead lines sound better on B to me - more natural and full - plus Hunter sounds like he's responding to the amp better in his playing  :)  Rhythm parts are muffled though, as said above....




hunter

Quote from: Twinfan on May 24, 2009, 12:05:43 PM
The lead lines sound better on B to me - more natural and full - plus Hunter sounds like he's responding to the amp better in his playing  :)  Rhythm parts are muffled though, as said above....





I agree with the leads. It was much louder when recording than yesterday, when I did the direct clips.

I did another version today, using the Recto New for the leads instead of the SLO, but again lower volume, here it is.
Tweaker's Paradise - Player's nightmare.

_tom_

My favourite is B as well. Just sounds more natural as twinfan says. C sounds very thin in comparison.
[url=http://soundcloud.com/shotgunroyale[Shotgun Royale[/url]

indysmith

Yeah I like B because it sounds like a real amp, lol. It's a bit more saggy. It doesn't mask your playing either.

The Axe seems like a great bit of gear, but I'm not convinced it's good enough to replace real valves yet!
[size=9px]LOVING the Mules![/size]

gwEm

my favourite is C. i reckon some post-prod eq tweaks could have covered up most of the differences though.
Quote from: AndyRyou wouldn't use the meat knife on crusty bread but, equally, the serrated knife and straight edge knife aren't going to go through raw meat as quickly

hunter


Did again some tweaking and reduced the gain/increased the openness a bit.

Now if this doesn't sound like Marshall, then I don't know what does , would you agree?

8)

http://www.klangforschungszentrum.de/temp/Immigrant_A_javi.mp3
Tweaker's Paradise - Player's nightmare.

dheim

the axe is more "professional" sounding, but strangely enough i prefer the marshall. muffled, yes, with that hideous buzzing overtones that i hate in marshalls, but much more dynamic and tight (maybe it was just your playing, changing a bit through the different takes, though)...
Mule, MQ, Stockholm, CS, RY, MM, PK, ANB, CNB, AWP, CWP, PiG90...

too many? ;)