I'm just personally torn, tbh. I've been advised to buy one or the other multiple times for my Les Paul and I am noe officially confused. I will list what I'm looking for in a pickup below, but rather than recommended me one or the other, could you kind of tell me 'why' that certain pickup would suit my needs and why the other one wouldn't?
The sound I'm looking for is a Drop-C Metal-core tone in a Les Paul. I'm a pickup that can play crushing riffs, but is also articulate enough to mix in fast single-string riffs. I like playing a lot of harmonised melodies as well. Regarding solos, I do like shredding on my bridge pickup now and again, but I also like to shred a lot on my neck pickups: so I'm looking for something in the neck that is also very articulate, that can track down sweeps very well also.
I mainly play music like Avenged, Bullet, Killswitch, etc.