but see, that's what I like about Tool. It is a bit dirgey, but at the same time, the riffs are wicked and the drumming is incredible, and Maynard's lyrics create a really great mood, you sort of 'get inside the song'. I can understand why someone wouldn't like them, it took me a long time to get into them, but now I love them. Having said that, I do think some fans get a bit carried away.
They remind me of Rush, which is a good thing!
I don't much like APC though; I find them quite bland.