I'm wondering whether the tiny little mark that sits about 0.75" below the pickup selector switch was counted as enough of a flaw in the top that they sent it for a solid finish instead?
In any case, I'm glad that the owner had the courage to uncover it, because that looks like pretty much the perfect Les Paul Standard in my opinion. For some reason, I love the tight "holographic" ribbon flames often seen on PRS, Music Man and Hamer guitars, but not on a traditional Les Paul.