• Welcome to Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum.
 

Gibson Classic 57' vs. the Mule?

Started by Mavet, May 25, 2007, 10:57:08 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Mavet

Hi
a friend of mine is building a Les Paul and wants it to sound as authentic as possible (he is a vintage kind of guy).
since he and computers don't get along very well I'm posting on his behalf.

can enyone who's had first hand experiance with bouth the Gibson Classic 57' and the Mule (in a les paul)comment on how they compare, which one achieves the original vintage Les Paul sound better and the pros/cons (if any) for each.

thanks

Ratrod

I haven't had the privilege to compare 'em head to head but I do know this:

Back in the old days Gibson wound their pickups by hand. The '57 Classic is wound by a machine.

The Mule is wound by hand.

I don't know how the measurements of the Gibson pups are but BKP's components (baseplate, covers etc.) are specced exactly like the old PAF's.
BKP user since 2004: early 7K Blackguard 50

Crazy_Joe

I would have thought it you want a vintage sound then you would keep the original pickups in there... i'm probably wrong but that seems to be the easiest way.
Black Dogs

Previous BKP's: Riff Raff, Holy Divers, Painkillers, C. Warpig, Nailbomb, Miracle Man.

Mavet

Quote from: Crazy_JoeI would have thought it you want a vintage sound then you would keep the original pickups in there... i'm probably wrong but that seems to be the easiest way.

He is building it from scrach 8)

Crazy_Joe

Black Dogs

Previous BKP's: Riff Raff, Holy Divers, Painkillers, C. Warpig, Nailbomb, Miracle Man.

PhilKing

I had a classsic 57's in my LP and swapped them for an Emerald and Mule.  The sound was worlds different.  It started me on changing all my pickups, I have now about 25 guitars with BK's.  He should go with the Mules, he will be really happy.
So many pickups, so little time

Philly Q

Because the old PAF pickups were handwound there isn't just one authentic vintage sound - some were overwound, some underwound, some might have an offset between the two coils.  And they used different magnets - Alnico II, III or IV (as Tim has mentioned elsewhere).

57 Classics are good pickups but they're only one "flavour" of vintage PAF - Mules, Stormy Mondays or many other manufacturers' PAF replicas are no less "authentic", they're just different.  I think you should get whatever sounds best to you.
BKPs I've Got:  RR, BKP-91, ITs, VHII, CS set, Emeralds
BKPs I Had:  RY+Abraxas, Crawlers, BD+SM

Tellboy

My '62 SG Reissue came with classic '57s. I thought they were quite good - definetely better than those that were  on my 1989 Les Paul Standard (which were assembled on PCBs! and sounded s**t) but not as good as the Riff Raffs I replaced them with.

IMO if you want real vintage LP sound I would go for a set of unpotted Mules in nickel covers plus an aluminium stop tailpiece (just ordered one from Jonathan at Feline).
John Suhr - "Practice cures most tone issues"
Crawler,Mule,Apache,Piledriver,Bl. Guard,Cold Sweat

steve

Quote from: PhilKingI had a classsic 57's in my LP and swapped them for an Emerald and Mule.  The sound was worlds different.  It started me on changing all my pickups, I have now about 25 guitars with BK's.  He should go with the Mules, he will be really happy.

+ 1.
Mule,Trilogy,Irish Tours,Holy Diver and Apaches.

HTH AMPS

I've had...

* SD Seth Lovers (played these for best part of ten years)
* SD  Antiquities (very Angus, but slightly too weak for me)
* SD '59s (ok if you've never tried any of the better PAF repros)
* DiMarzio Virtual PAFs (much like 'SD '59s, average)
* Timbuckers (wound by a guy on the LPF, very nice pickups)
* WCR Fillmores (no comment)
* Gibson T-tops from 70s (alot like SD Antiquities)

I now have Mules and they're far better than any of the above (except the Timbuckers which are only slightly pipped by the Mules being a bit sweeter - might be the magnet choice).

:twisted:
[url="//www.youtube.com/TeleCustom72"]www.youtube.com/TeleCustom72[/url]
www.soundclick.com/bands/default.cfm?bandID=876738
www.facebook.com/pages/HTH-Amplification/263958270289235?sk=wall

Mavet

thanks for all the replies.
can enyone compare the classic 57' and the Mule EQ-wise
thanks?

HTH AMPS

Quote from: Mavetthanks for all the replies.
can enyone compare the classic 57' and the Mule EQ-wise
thanks?

oh, I missed out the classic 57s I had - thinner, brighter and harder sounding than the Mules.

:twisted:
[url="//www.youtube.com/TeleCustom72"]www.youtube.com/TeleCustom72[/url]
www.soundclick.com/bands/default.cfm?bandID=876738
www.facebook.com/pages/HTH-Amplification/263958270289235?sk=wall

sskint

why no comment on the fillmores?

ericsabbath

Quote from: PhilKingI have now about 25 guitars with BK's.


:!:  :!:  :!:  :!:  :!:

give me one!
just one!  :oops:
Riff Raff, Mules, Black Dog, VHII's, Cold Sweat