Ok it was a decision I had to make out of 2 possible guys, but I'm going with....
Robb Flynn: Okay he's not the greatest shredder that ever lived, but here are my reasons.
1. Tone: Well the tone on the first 2 Machine Head albums was absolutely crushing! It was hard, dirty, had massive balls and made you listen. Then it changed for the Burning red and Supercharger and I hated it, just glad they've changed again for the better this time!
2. Stage Presence: This guy knows how to get his crowds going, but he also knows who helped put him up there in the first place and is really appreciative of his fans.
3. I can relate: Okay so his teenage / young adult years were a lot harsher than mine from what I can gather, but he's the kind of guy that did the same as me when I was younger: got himself into shitety situations but through pure will dragged himself out of it, and I respect that in anybody, let alone someone who has come out of it and gone on that extra mile and made a success of his life. Bravo to the chap really.
4. Writing: Come on, you know it! Davidian, Ten Ton Hammer etc. The guy can RIFF! Even the most simple of his riffs are just so powerful you can't ignore them. You can really FEEL the energy and feelings he puts into those riffs. I was playing Ten Ton Hammer the other day, it's just open string to 1st fret over and over on the main riff. If anyone else had done it, it would sound like they hadn't bothered, but Robb knew what he was doing on this one and poured his attitude into it and it really comes across.
5. Gambles and correction: He headed up a band that almost shouldn't have worked. At the time the sound was fresh and the rap references were all over the place to see and hear. He took his sound and went with it and it just really paid off. And then he went ahead and released the Burning red and Supercharger, he took a gamble there and to a lot of original fans it didn't pay off very well at all. A lot of us (myself included) felt a little let down, but a bands gotta do what they gotta do. He experimented and put it out there. For a lot of us it went wrong, but then he released Through the Ashes of Empires and not only did they get all the old fans salivating again, the new fans were more than eager to follow on this sound that was new to them. Correction at its best! :D