• Welcome to Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum.
 

Kung Fu V Tae Kwon Do!!

Started by Johnny Mac, August 19, 2008, 09:02:34 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Johnny Mac

Warpig, MQ,
Miracle Man-Trilogy Suite, Cold Sweats, Black Guards, Rebel Yells & Irish Tours!

Ian Price

I think Kung Fu man owned him. Completely.
I think I hate being indecisive.

MrBump

Interesting stuff...  you tube is great for that sorta thing...

I've been involved with martial arts for over twenty years, and I'm always fascinated by different styles and their effectiveness against other styles...
BKPs Past and Present - Nailbombs, Mules, Blackguard Flat 50's, VHII's & Trilogy Suite with Neck & Bridge Baseplates!

Bird

I wouldn't want to rely on either one in a fight.  :)
"Jazz isn't dead, it just smells funny." Frank Zappa

Davey

#4
it's good, when you've put some much time into a martial art, that executing the moves with precision becomes second nature. till then, it's better not to get in a fight, cos you'll just embarras yourself.

as for this lil vid.. one of them was good at kicking and dodging, the other wasn't and that's pretty much all that you can see there. they're probably amateurs too, cos the red one kept using the same tricks over and over and the white one didn't even pick up on that. when your oponents main strenght is kicking, you don't back away either, you got to get close, grab him by the ankles, and carry him out of the ring lol ... though the fun starts when he's got a knife and you don't
[url="http://soundcloud.com/DeclineOfSociety"]http://soundcloud.com/DeclineOfSociety[/url]
[url="http://soundcloud.com/IgorVonE"]http://soundcloud.com/IgorVonE[/url]

shobet

I think a contest - note I didn't say fight - like this doesn't really show much about either of the arts being used. The situation is not representative of a real flight, where being on the losing side could have dire consequences.

I went off competitive sparring years ago as it didn't really add to what I considered my martial education. In my opinion it just developed ego, and the façade that you're any good at fighting. 

The way people train and their mental attitude towards their training really does have a major effect on whatever art you're studying and then what comes out under stress if you have to use it one day. Those endless hours marching up and down the dojo doing the same move over and over until it's in the subconscious means bugger all unless you can do that under real stress. If you're not going to get hit when you miss a block when sparing, then you're not going develop the ability to react when the adrenalin dumps and you're in real fear of you life. Also it means than when someone really does plant one on you, that you can deal with that surprise to your system that stops people not used to getting the odd knock in their tracks. If you know your partner is not going to hit you if you miss a block, then he/she, and the school you are training at are doing you a disservice. You may as well go and do aerobics, as you are not training in a martial art.

Ooops a daisy, that turned into a little rant.

Anyway back to it, wipe on, wipe off, wipe on, wipe off, wipe...
There are 10 kinds of people who understand binary.
Those who do and those who do not.

ToneMonkey

Interesting, I always saw sparing as an increase in my skills (I did Wado Ryu BTW).  It was my favorite part of training.

We were all taught though that technique between sparing and a real scr@p are very different and that if we were in a real scr@p that neatness went out of the window.  If you had to fight, then make sure you end it very quickly, preferably with taking their teeth completetly out their mouth............ that's why I like Wado Ryu (a very old traditional karate), it was very practical  :D
Advice worth what you just paid for it.

noodleplugerine

Quote from: shobet on August 20, 2008, 08:47:21 PM
I think a contest - note I didn't say fight - like this doesn't really show much about either of the arts being used. The situation is not representative of a real flight, where being on the losing side could have dire consequences.

I went off competitive sparring years ago as it didn't really add to what I considered my martial education. In my opinion it just developed ego, and the façade that you're any good at fighting. 

The way people train and their mental attitude towards their training really does have a major effect on whatever art you're studying and then what comes out under stress if you have to use it one day. Those endless hours marching up and down the dojo doing the same move over and over until it's in the subconscious means bugger all unless you can do that under real stress. If you're not going to get hit when you miss a block when sparing, then you're not going develop the ability to react when the adrenalin dumps and you're in real fear of you life. Also it means than when someone really does plant one on you, that you can deal with that surprise to your system that stops people not used to getting the odd knock in their tracks. If you know your partner is not going to hit you if you miss a block, then he/she, and the school you are training at are doing you a disservice. You may as well go and do aerobics, as you are not training in a martial art.

Ooops a daisy, that turned into a little rant.

Anyway back to it, wipe on, wipe off, wipe on, wipe off, wipe...


+1, you learn far more from cleaning cars than you do from non contact fighting.
[url=http://tinyurl.com/5c64mh]My last FM.[/url]
ESP Horizon NTII.
ESP Viper Camo.
ENGL Screamer.

Sifu Ben

The thing with Eshan Shafiq is that he posts all these edited fights on Youtube of him fighting people who aren't very good. Apparently he does Mizhongquan, but you really wouldn't know from watching him fight, he just does a load of flashy kicking which works because he's fighting below par opposition.
Quoteit's good, when you've put some much time into a martial art, that executing the moves with precision becomes second nature. till then, it's better not to get in a fight, cos you'll just embarras yourself.
That's not really true, a good school should be able to develop combat skill incrementally, so you're becoming a better fighter from the get go. One of my students gave up because he was horrified at how badly he FUBARd someone in a fight after 6 months training.
Cold Sweat, Nailbomb 7b, Cold Sweat 7n

Sifu Ben

Quote from: Bird on August 20, 2008, 03:59:44 AM
I wouldn't want to rely on either one in a fight.  :)
Now now, you know my Sifu and your Sensei are friends. Funny story, the first time they met Diego goes "You do Kung Fu? Then I am very sorry. I am sorry you have wasted your life on that sh*t" , So they fight, and afterwards Diego concedes that there's Kung Fu and there's Kung Fu, and they've been firm friends ever since.
Are you fighting in the next Guardian Challenge? My Sifu's hoping to field a decent team this year.
Cold Sweat, Nailbomb 7b, Cold Sweat 7n

Davey

Quote from: Sifu Ben on August 21, 2008, 04:34:03 PM
Quoteit's good, when you've put some much time into a martial art, that executing the moves with precision becomes second nature. till then, it's better not to get in a fight, cos you'll just embarras yourself.
That's not really true, a good school should be able to develop combat skill incrementally, so you're becoming a better fighter from the get go. One of my students gave up because he was horrified at how badly he FUBARd someone in a fight after 6 months training.
well, i didnt say how much time.. some arts take a while, till you get to a decent level (Aikido for example) others are better at picking up (like karate), but it all comes down to the individual and the talent one has. someone can have classes each day and after 5 years, he still wont be able to land a hit, while others show quite some advancement after a couple of months. and yes, a proper school helps.. not like the one i studied karate at ... geez
[url="http://soundcloud.com/DeclineOfSociety"]http://soundcloud.com/DeclineOfSociety[/url]
[url="http://soundcloud.com/IgorVonE"]http://soundcloud.com/IgorVonE[/url]

Bird

Quote from: Sifu Ben on August 21, 2008, 04:37:55 PM
Quote from: Bird on August 20, 2008, 03:59:44 AM
I wouldn't want to rely on either one in a fight.  :)
Now now, you know my Sifu and your Sensei are friends. Funny story, the first time they met Diego goes "You do Kung Fu? Then I am very sorry. I am sorry you have wasted your life on that sh*t" , So they fight, and afterwards Diego concedes that there's Kung Fu and there's Kung Fu, and they've been firm friends ever since.
Are you fighting in the next Guardian Challenge? My Sifu's hoping to field a decent team this year.
That sounds exactly like him :) Yes I'll be in the tournament this year (heavyweight). Apparently we're going to have a senior category for 40 yrs and up.If you PM me your address I can sent you a copy of the dvds I made of last years tournament. My fight isn't on there as it would've been too hard to hold the camcorder. ;)
"Jazz isn't dead, it just smells funny." Frank Zappa

Johnny Mac

I thought the Afghan's reactions were lighting fast.

All this talk about sparring not being effective in a real fight for and against, well for me here's the reality of a real fight in GB. Pubs and alcohol being the fuel that causes them and the chavs who indulge in this sort of thing more than other members of society. Realistically all anyone would have to do to avoid being hit is footwork and the odd dodge, within a minute they will be out of breath. You could if you felt like it say 'finish him' like that voice in the game and do the prick with a roundhouse kick but really all you would have to do i walk off.
Warpig, MQ,
Miracle Man-Trilogy Suite, Cold Sweats, Black Guards, Rebel Yells & Irish Tours!

Afghan Dave

Quote from: Johnny Mac on August 21, 2008, 07:51:54 PM
I thought the Afghan's reactions were lighting fast.

When I make love I come like the thunder!

Nice clip

It seems like everybody on this board is kung fu fighting...In fact, it's a little bit frightening.. :lol: :lol:
"There's more knowledge on these boards than there are necks under PhillyQ's bed"

broken cord


Tourney's are all well and good. I studied GoJu Ryu, but in a street fight it's whatever works. There is only one rule...Win. :shock: :shock:
Warpig/Mississippi Queen
Calibrated Painkillers
Nailbombs