Installed my second set of Blackguard Flat 50s at the weekend... 8)
The first set went in my Baja Tele, and that really brought the thing alive for me - I'd been seriously struggling with liking it and with understanding how to play a tele until I put the blaggards in. Apart from when she was away getting a refret, she's been my "go to" guitar ever since.
Then a couple of months back I scored a second hand Japanese 52 re-issue, cheap enough to not be able to say no(!). I believe it had Texas Specials (might be "US Vintage" pickups, though they seemed a bit more powerful in the mids than the Blackguards). These were ok, but not really doing it for me - so I put the Baja's old pickups in for a few weeks to see what I thought. The Baja's pups were a great improvement - more articulate, etc, etc...
But it just didn't sound as good for me as the Baja with her Blaggards...
I debated long and hard - she sounded fine with the Baja's pups, just not quite my kind of tele, not quite enough meat to the tone. The Baja pups are just a little too "polite sounding" for me - loads of top end but no grind. She was sounding light and melodic, and great as a strumming rhythm guitar, but I don't do a lot of the latter, and the BKP'd Baja does all that as well...
I had wondered whether I really ought to be keeping the guitars different, trying different tele BKPs, but the look of the thing was just screaming "give me the early 50s vibe ma-an...", and then the clincher was when I realised I always get the same curry from the takeaway, so what's wrong with me getting the same pickups twice! :lol:
So I decided to get her the Flat 50s to install after christmas. And then they arrived somewhat faster than I expected (!)...
I put them in on sunday, and the difference is every bit as stunning as it was for the Baja. It's still got all the top end and bite, but there's just a bit more munchiness to the Flat 50s. And funnily enough, I'm also more inclined to strumming rhythm on it now :roll:
I used to pick her up and try to love her, but only play for 5 minutes before putting her down to see how the BKPd Baja compared... I can't put her down now (actually I can, my fingers hurt!)
I can't vouch for the other BKP tele pups - but I love the Blackguard Flat 50s. If you're a blues, country-blues, classic rock, rocknroll, sort of player, who's after a traditional and versatile tele set, with plenty of oommph when you need it - I don't think you can go far wrong with these...