The Metroamp kits different mainly in the transformers and the use of PEC 2W Mil Spec Pots, just good quality hardware and iron and as most guitar amp builders will tell you the transformer is the heart of the amp, George at Metro has cloned his 67 and 68 spec plexi's output via heyboer and they're bloody close copies with a helluva lotta tone going on.
Nik's Iron is just a good modern spec transformer using new production materials and standards, it's not imperial sized laminations, I understand it's got the interleaved pattern from the originals but the insulation material is different which makes a difference, and the steel that is used today is not to the same specs it was back in the day for the laminations, where as Metro's Iron is very close to the original.
Another major factory in the amps tone is the coupling caps used Nik uses Mallory 150s and Metro use Sozo, the main difference in coupling caps is the ESR which is the resistance the cap provides against the signal, Sozo has a much higher ESR than Mallory 150 which contibutes to a sweeter tone, less highs, more mids and fatter overall tone.
I've tried all these products and I'm a firm believer in the fact the Metro stuff is in another league tone wise, but then again so it a great original example of a plexi ya just can't quite copy what 30 years of use does to an amp.
I have owned 3 Ceriatone amps. All have been of a very good quality. My perception is that they are definately a step above the Weber kits, but not quite up to the vintage accuracy of a Metroamp kit.
Vintage accuracy in looks? I agree, Metroamp kits have the 'look'.
With regard to tone, there won't be a lot (if anything) in it. And as Marshall changed specs like their underpants back in the sixties, there is no one reference 'tone' anyway!
The Ceriatone stuff is great Indy, drop Nik an email and fill your boots :D