• Welcome to Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum.
 

Les Paul Copy

Started by varkunus, February 07, 2010, 09:36:01 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Twinfan

The price difference is there for various reasons - country of manufacture, build quality, QC, raw materials etc.

Only you can decide if the more expensive model is truly "worth it".


Philly Q

BKPs I've Got:  RR, BKP-91, ITs, VHII, CS set, Emeralds
BKPs I Had:  RY+Abraxas, Crawlers, BD+SM

Twinfan


Ian Price

Quote from: Twinfan on February 09, 2010, 12:04:33 PM
Only you can decide if the more expensive model is truly "worth it".

This sounds like the voice of experience  :)
I think I hate being indecisive.

Twinfan

Exactly!

I've bought and sold a few guitars over the years  ;)

varkunus

OK may sound a bit odd, but if you gave the MIJ tokais an overall rating for 10 on the following. How would the vintage score comparitively on the following...

Sound -
Raw materials -
construction quality -
playability -

Twinfan

Dude - enough already.

Find a shop with some in stock and play them both and see what YOU think.  It's always worth a day trip to check out guitars  :)

Ian Price

I really think you should try some for yourself. What some rate as a 10 others may rate as a 7 etc etc etc. It's very difficult to be specific about the details in differences between 2 guitars on a forum - the only real way of telling is trying.

Just my opinion of course.
I think I hate being indecisive.

Ian Price

Dave beat me to it!

Seriously, try some out and decide what you like. I love my strat, Dave doesn't like strats that much. It doesn't make my guitar a 'great' guitar and an 'okay' guitar at the same time. It's all about personal opinion.

And yes, a day out in a guitar shop is a great way of finding out what works for you  8)
I think I hate being indecisive.

varkunus

No ofc I know this. But what I am getting is at is how much worse is the build quality of the vintage compared to the more expensive mij tokais. So if someone here has played MIJ tokais and a vintage v100 les paul style guitar. How would describe the differences between guitars. Thats what I am getting at. I live on the isle of wight and guitar shops are limited here so I might have to get shops to specially order in stuff - hence why I am trying to narrow it down as much as possible. But I fully appreciate I need to try. Like i said I am merely trying to compare the general difference in quality between the 2 guitars, and trying to work out if the price difference warrants the quality difference etc.

thanks

Afghan Dave

"There's more knowledge on these boards than there are necks under PhillyQ's bed"

Twinfan

I've played both.  They're different.  The Vintage feels "cheaper", but I'd be happy to gig either.  I'd buy whichever sounded the best.

dave_mc

#43
Quote from: Twinfan on February 08, 2010, 10:07:11 PM
I believe it does Dave, yep.

cheers, dave. Worth bearing in mind, then- if you're going for the custom model because you like the looks (over the LP standard look), but if you've already got a standard and are going for the custom for the spec, then that'd be a concern, kind of thing. :)

Quote from: varkunus on February 09, 2010, 12:16:07 AM
I'm aware that the amp is the main player in tone, but I do think guitars make quite a big difference - albeit subtley. At the moment I am drawn to the vintage les paul lemon drop, but how does it this compare to the MIJ tokais. I mean what is the difference in playbility, tone/wood quality and overall build quality. Has anyone played both a v100 and tokais and so could offer good comparissions?

i don't want to say too much, as i haven't tried that exact model of vintage (and I'm not sure if i've tried the exact tokai model you're talking about, either), but any MIJ tokai I've tried has been in a different league from any vintage I've tried. Like the difference between a (good) gibson and an epiphone.

i agree with everyone saying you really need to try them.

EDIT: just realised you said you lived on the IoW- that's different. I live in NI, and I get a bit annoyed when people tell me to try stuff for which we have no dealers (or chide me for buying online- again, when we have no dealers and when they haven't been in a lot of the local shops here which seem to have stock for 4 years without even so much as a string change :lol: ). And judging by the size of it, if anything the IoW is worse for getting to try gear than Northern Ireland is.

For me, personally (and bearing in mind that I haven't tried the exact models you're talking about, but I've tried quite a few vintages and MIJ tokais of other models), the MIJ Tokai would be worth the increase in price every single time, assuming I could afford it, of course. This is because, for me personally, the Vintage (any I've tried, anyway- we may get the rejects here in NI) isn't "good enough", whereas the Tokai is. Everyone's idea of what is "good enough" is different, though, and that's why you get such a variety of different opinions.

tomjackson


Since you can't try the guitars and sound like you can stretch to the MIJ, get one of those, they are fine guitars.
The Vintage is good but get a Tokai and there will never be any doubt in your mind, you have a real Les Paul in all but name.

Do it.  On your Credit Card. Now.