Extreme words of wisdom from master MDV here:
"...an important part of it is understanding what you've done and being able to repeat it when you need/want to..."
(Sounds like you've been through the "sh1t!! that's brilliant... (imho :lol:) ...now, how the f*** did I do it?!!" a fair few times as well...)
"You try to repeat successes, but experimentation doesnt and never should leave the recording process..."
I've just "unlearnt" how I've recorded vocals, the "performing part" anyway, for the past XX-years. I always used to stand, remove all jangly items, address the mic, get all psyched up to summon a performance, get wound up by noises from outside (or inside) the flat/whatever. I did this for all "non-guide vox", including backing vox.
The other week, for a huge wall of backing vox, I couldn't be @rsed with all the running around between mic and machine - and I thought I was just practising/experimenting anyway.... So I set up so's I could sit on the sofa and reach machine with hands, and mic with mouth, and see machine with eyes... all without moving my head (or my behind from the carefully crafted @rse-groove at my end of the sofa :lol:)
It turned out fantastic - and I used all the parts, most of them first takes... So on the next song I tried doing the lead vocal like that as well. That seemed to work too! Not sure I could do a "rock vocal" without standing up... but for general vocal work I shall be using the "Homer Simpson" position for vocal performances unless I can't reach a note or vibe I want :lol:
On the learning new things (ie when one actually understands what has just happened and knows how to repeat it): How much do you find yourself tempted to "go back and redo" based on what you've just learnt from a later project?
I get this most on the mixing and "producing" stage... the hacking around with the multi-tracks. But sometimes I'll find out a basic track could have been better if I'd done xyz that I've just discovered instead...
But I've reached the conclusion that life's too short - much as I'd like to redo it, it's not as if the item in question is about to go into any life-or-death money-making situation, and I'm still learning anyway... tomorrow I'll learn something that makes me want to redo it again for different reasons!! :lol: