i think it's odd looking, but not a disaster. if i saw it in a shop i'd certainly want to give it a go! i think the three volumes in a row is a good idea, but i agree they should have moved the tone a bit further away. the five way switch is definately a good idea though, i never liked the switching on three pickup gibsons.
it's a beautiful looking guitar with an odd headstock, something which hasn't put a lot of you off Tylers :)