Ok, so the more I think about it, I might try the MM. I REALLY like the Steve's Special in my MM JP, which seems to have a similar EQ style/output as the MM (albeit in a basswood body).
Thoughts?
EDIT: After reading so much praise for the RY and the fact that it gets so many awesome overtones and a more organic sound, I'm leaning on maybe trying them out; I'm not sure how they'd do in a very thin mahogany body, but the same goes for all the other pickups!
Now, I've successfully gone from wanting PK's, VHII's, CS's, MM's, and RY's in this guitar. I might as well just put it up to a vote!