From what you describe, it's the NOS that would get me as well.
Looks are important to me - I won't try a guitar if it doesn't appeal looks-wise. So I'm guessing that the NOS is almost there for you on it's appearance anyway. But if you touch a guitar that goes "PLAY ME!!!" to you, you're kind of sunk.
I tried a 60's sunburst Roadworn (less dangerous price-range, but still the same effect :lol:) because I was curious about them. I wasn't convinced about the relic thing, and in the shop it certainly had the odd minus because of it. But looks-wise it was "OK" and would improve. However, the moment I touched it I couldn't put it down, looks went out the window.
I'm not quite as strat-centric as Frank, but I'm pretty close. That Roadworn is probably my "this one stays, the rest could go if necessary...". It's not my easiest-to-play guitar, and it doesn't cut it when I'm in "I fancy humbuckers at the moment", but there's something about the way it sounds and responds - all I've got to do is brush the strings in passing and it says "pick me up and play me".
Sounds like the NOS could do that to you.
And btw, Frank, that wine red, YUMMY!!