Thanks for the response! So you think the rebel yell can handle heavier gain while also tightening up the bass response? Have you ever played one of these in the bridge in a les paul?
I haven't had the chance to play one, I've only heard recordings. There are no really good recordings of it playing the heavier style of stuff you like, as far as I know, but there is a video of the 8 string version that gives the impression that it can handle a bit of bottom end.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3QGpa_HOsbUhttp://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zohVcKcSdeYThose 8 string players always seem to be into djent though :?
There are some threads here around the place from people who have put them in various mahogany guitars. Not one bad report that I've read, although someone did swap the bridge out for a VHII on a Les Paul because it wasn't really his thing.
I expected littleredguitars2 to be all over this, but he seems to be away.
If you went for the Nailbomb you would probably be happier with the alnico version, but it doesn't like some thinner bodied, middier sounding mahogany guitars, like most SGs. The RY on the other hand works well on either SGs or the bassier Gibsons like Les Pauls and Explorers. The A-Bomb just seems to clash with the resonant qualities of the SG. Some people have been warned off of Nailbombs for Explorers due to the Explorer being too dark. Unless the guitar is the same as yours it's hard to go by these discussions. I would say that the RY is a safe bet. Others are less safe. littleredguitars2 had a Nailbomb and didn't like it for pop punk, but that was in a Strat and he replaced it with a Stockholm P-90. TBH having used a Nailbomb - admittedly in an SG, which wasn't the smartest gamble - I'd say its punk qualities lie outside of the kind of punk you like, much more in the hardcore vein, and everything seems to have a hardcore edge to it with the Nailbomb. If you want to play stuff like The Exploited, Poison Idea, RDP, Sepultura, etc go for it, it's a no-brainer for those styles. It does have a very distinctive sound that immediately evokes those bands for me. It can do other things, but its scope depends very much on your guitar. In general the more mid-focused your guitar is the more hardcore it sounds.