Username: Password:

Author Topic: Black Dog in strat review  (Read 3438 times)

PK

  • Flyweight
  • *
  • Posts: 87
  • BKPs: VHII Bridge, Emerald Neck, HD Bridge
Black Dog in strat review
« on: February 02, 2017, 10:56:26 AM »
Guitar: Fender Am std 2013 Strat with a FU upgrades brass block and a maple fretboard.
Amps: Victory VX Kraken, Budda Superdrive II 18 watts, Egnater Tweaker.

A while back I found a second hand Black Dog that I could buy for a decent price. So I though, let’s make my SSS strat into a SSH strat. The BD was zebra, and I love the look of a zebra bucker and 2 singles.

The guitar with the Black Dog in it initially sounded uninspiring, a bit flat, lacking some life.
After some help from Ben from BKP I upgraded the electronics from 3x250k pots (with a tone pot for the bridge) to a 500k volume and 2x250k pots for both single coils.
This opened up the guitar a lot!

Side note: I emailed BKP to ask what they would recommend for this guitar. I was basically looking to buy new pickups. But Ben was initially hesitant to give me the advice that I wanted. Instead he gave me the advice I needed............so thnx Ben!!

I can't say I am in love with this guitar yet, the single coils (Fat50s) are OK, but not really what I'm looking for. Therefore I ordered 2 63's. Once they arrive I'll write another review for those.

But, back to the Black Dog.
The Black Dog is a very nice pickup!! I does what it says on the tin! And it does it well.
If you play a lot of complex chords in a low to medium gain situation, this is your pickup.
The BD makes chords Rock! They are a little dry, dynamic and fat.

For leads it's not my thing. The BD does not make my guitar sing like the HD and Jugg do.

When I switched to Channel 2 of my Kraken (and by this point I was tuned to Drop C#) I started to get a big grin on my face.
The BD does low tunings really well!!!! As in fat, thick, defined and never flubby.
The low end is not super tight like the C-Bomb or the Jugg, but nice and chubby, in a good way.
The mids carry some weight, the mids kinda remind me more of the Jugg than of the C-Bomb or HD.
The highs are a little subdued, but it's not a dull pickup.

Things got a little problematic for me though when I plugged into the Budda.
This is a fat sounding amp, with a very fat sounding speaker.
But when cranked, this amp has a lot of sag, at home this sounds nice and fat. In a band this did not work out well for me.

All in all I really like this pickup. But maybe not in this guitar.
But if it is a riffing monster you are looking for, this is it!
I am looking to get a baritone in the near future, I think this would be an ideal pickup for that.

After sorting out the Pots issue, Ben later advised me to look into a Rebel Yell for this guitar.

Slartibartfarst42

  • Welterweight
  • ****
  • Posts: 2125
  • Random Solution
Re: Black Dog in strat review
« Reply #1 on: February 02, 2017, 04:04:17 PM »
I wouldn't have thought a Rebel Yell would work in a Strat with a maple fingerboard as it's a bright pickup in a bright guitar. The usual wisdom is that a Rebel Yell is made for a Les Paul.

As for the Black Dog, I've always really fancied one of these and even though your review points out limitations, I'm not put off in the slightest. I think this is probably because I also never thought of putting a Black Dog in a Strat because I've always envisaged it in a Les Paul. Unfortunately, I only have one Les Paul and the pickups already in there, I love and have no intention of changing. I also generally only use 43AWG wire in bridge humbuckers so the 42.5AWG in the Black Dog perhaps makes me hesitate more than I should. Either way, the Black Dog always strikes me as a bit of an unsung hero so it's great to see it getting some attention.
BKP owned:

Bridge - Emerald; Cold Sweat; Crawler; A-Bomb; Holydiver; Miracle Man; Sinner; Trilogy Suite

Neck - Emerald; Cold Sweat; Crawler; Holydiver; Sinner; Trilogy Suite