• Welcome to Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum.
 

Is it just me?

Started by wixomwhat, June 15, 2005, 05:32:21 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

wixomwhat

Am I the only person who doesn't like A5 magnets?

I think they sound fine in Single coil pickups but sound (for the most part) terrible in Humbuckers.
I do like Dimarzios Humbucker from Hell- but thats supposed to sound like a single coil so I dunno if it counts.

So people has great tones with pickups that have A5's but They just dont work for me.

Ceramics seem perfect for me in humbuckers. Even PAFish type pickups, I think they sound better with Ceramics.

What about you guys? Dislike any magnet type? prefer one over the other etc, etc?

TwilightOdyssey

Don't say that! I just ordered a VHII!!! LOL

Diff'rent strokes for diff'rent folks, man ...

wixomwhat

Sorry Bro. I'm sure your new Pup will sound great!  :D

TwilightOdyssey

I've actually always been a fan of the A5 magnet, and have only recently been converted to the joys of a great ceramic pup ...

Tim

Ceramics do a great job where gain is involved but they're way to efficient for cleans or vintage tone and sound hard and clinical if used in a PAF type design.
Alnico V is a great magnet when used in the right context.I use it where power is required or a big wind needs to be powered. You try powering a DC16K sets of coils with  A2,A3 or A4 and they'll sound like mush-all mids no highs.OK this is where ceramics come into their own but A5's too and if you want a more organic tone and sweeter cleans then A5s rule the roost.
Let's take TOs VHII now winging it's way over the water, the DC of the 52mm spaced coils is DC9.2K, wound with 42 AWG plain enamel-this is hot for that type of wire.Put an A2 under those coils and the definition goes, likewise A4, ceramic brings the bottom up way too much and turns the highs to glass, A5 sits just right.It's down to square peg,square hole.........I spent months winding, playing diferent versions of this one-HJM was involved too and had an early prototype.The wind evolved hugely and it features an unusal offset-I'm not trying to claim I invented the wheel here but the pickup is tuned totally by ear. OK, it's called a VHII and will get you into the early EVH tone ballpark-but it's a VERY versatile pickup and what you do with it is down to you as a player. It won't make you sound like Eddie-nothing will-you can go plug into Eddies rig with his guitar and you won't sound like him-that part of the tone is in the player.It will put you on the right side of the fence and deliver the vibe but it's capable of doing so much.
So, as with all my pickups, excuse my artistic licence with the names, I like to indulge myself alittle :D  and give a hint of where you're starting from with one of my pickups.Where you go with it is down to you....................
Tim
BKP - "Wound, made and played the traditional way --- by hand!" Amen.

HJM

The A5 VHII is so much better than the last one I had (AIV I think!).

I had Tim send me some magnets, and happily spent a week swapping magnets around. And I have to say, Tim's choices were spot on!
Apache,VHII,Emerald,Nailbomb,MiracleMan,StormyMonday,BlackDog,Trilogy,Mothersmilk,Sultans+Sinner

Ratrod

I think it's not the magnet you dislike. I think the pickups you heard as a whole sucked. Did you hear some of the clip? Most of them are A5. I don't hear anything wrong with them.
BKP user since 2004: early 7K Blackguard 50

PhilKing

I like A5's but Tim turned me on to the A4/A5 combo and this really sounds nice.  I am a classic rock/blues player and for me the A5 really powers the pickup.  I have Crawler, VHII, Emerald, Pig-90, p-90's, Miracle Man (the bridge in a clibrated set), RiffRaff (Tim recommended this to work with a Stormy Monday with A4), NailBomb and Trilogies all with A5's and they all sound great  :boulet:

That said, all my BKP's sound great, so perhaps the magnet is not really an issue.  Which A5 pickups did you hear that you didn't like?
So many pickups, so little time

wixomwhat

Guys- I'm not trying to bash any pickups here. Like I said, some guys sound Killer with A5 loaded pickups, actually alot of guys do, I just can't get the pups i've tried to work for me.

Quote from: RatrodI think it's not the magnet you dislike. I think the pickups you heard as a whole sucked. Did you hear some of the clip? Most of them are A5. I don't hear anything wrong with them.

Thats what I'm talking about, those clips are Awsome!

It must be my set up or the way I play or something. Ceramic + distortion= good tone for me.

A5+ Distortion= Mid/Mud city.

I set my amp like this- Highs=6, Mids=6 and Low=5.5

willo

ive just spent the past hour playing with my VHII's and i think i am close to nailing my perfect tone...it sounds awesome, soooo nice.


just playing into a plexi modeller (i aim to get a real one maybe), and through a Catalinbread Clean Boost, its not muddy at all, but defined and articulate but with lots of grunt and power.

(i just wanted to say that :wink: )

anyway, i was thinking about tone yesterday and at the end of the day, somethings work for some people and some don't for others. Different strokes for different folks and all that. What A5 pickups have you tried, and what kind of music do you play?
The large print giveth, and the small print taketh away...

TwilightOdyssey

I think wixom is a metalhead, unless I'm mistaken.

Ratrod

A5 magnets enhance the lows and highs, not the mids, right?

Mid/muddy pickups are usually overwound. However most BKP's have a lot of winds and the Crawler, for example, is middy but not muddy at all. Must be the scatterwinding.

How am I doing so far?
BKP user since 2004: early 7K Blackguard 50

wixomwhat

Quote from: TwilightOdysseyI think wixom is a metalhead, unless I'm mistaken.

Your correct  :)

I guess my style is thrash mixed with 80's hair metal.

Though my favorite bands are Maiden, Dio, Megadeth, Children of Bodom and ... Weezer- lol. Rivers Coumo can really rip.

wixomwhat

The whole LA metal scene is what I love. Big hair, Great guitar playing and Kramers, badass IMO.



But yeah like I said, Maiden and Bodom and stuff are my Favorites.

wixomwhat

other stuff I'm into includes

Def Leppard, Journey, Bon Jovi, Queen, King's X, and Rush.