Yep. It's all about the best singers. Until it comes to TV ratings.
We really should stop going on about this on this thread :oops: , but....
I don't believe it
is about the best singers. I know Cowell sometimes says "it's a singing contest", but five minutes later he says "you need to be an all-round entertainer" or "nice voice, but you're not a pop star" - basically he uses whatever argument suits him at that moment.
But it's not called "Best Singer", it's called "The X Factor" - that (IMO) means something intangible, star quality, charisma, whatever you want to call it.
Iggy Pop can't sing for toffee, but he sure as hell has "The X Factor". Hardly anyone on XF (the show) ever does. That includes Leona Lewis, by the way, who's beautiful and has a fine voice.... but all the personality and charisma of a fencepost.
At least John & Edward are entertaining - that means they deserve to be there, IMO. And
somebody's voting for them.