• Welcome to Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum.
 

only one pickup?

Started by markofled, September 24, 2008, 06:55:38 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

markofled

Just bought an italia maranello speedster. VERY nice guitar considering price. Anyway It only has a humbucker in the bridge which is ok but it like to put a Bare Knuckles pup in. Im thinking either mule or missippi queen for versatility. What would you recommend and if you had a guitar with one pup which BK would you put in and why?

TwilightOdyssey


AndyR

Like what TO says, it would depend on what I was trying to achieve.

For my usual style of playing, vintage rock sounds and mainly blues, blues/rock, pop, I'd choose Mississippi Queen - without even thinking. It gives me "almost" humbucker but less compressed. Backing off the volume it's definitely a single coil but fat. That would give me the most versatility in a single pup guitar.

However, if I was playing heavier stuff I'd be looking at one of the high output ones, one that cleans up nicely. I seem to remember I've been recommend nailbomb, warpig, and crawler for that sort of thing in the past - but don't quote me, I haven't actually tried them yet! :lol:
Play or Download AndyR Music at [url="http://www.alonetone.com/andyr"]http://www.alonetone.com/andyr[/url]

Philly Q

I'm not sure about recommendations, but I have two single-pickup guitars with BKPs - a Les Paul Jr with a BKP-91 and an SG-X with a Riff Raff.  Basically because you put P-90s in LP Jrs and Riff Raffs in SGs!  :lol:

I find the BKP-91 great for clean sounds and gnarly old-school blues-rock tones (Leslie West!), but it lacks a humbucker's tight crunch for really distorted tones (Andy may disagree!  :wink: ). 

As for the Riff Raff, it's just a good basic not-too-hot humbucker tone; I have it wired with a series/parallel switch which increases the versatility a fair bit - I guess you'd get quite similar results with a Mule.

I haven't tried one (yet!) but I expect the VHII would be good in a single pickup Strat, for obvious reasons.   And if I didn't already have the Riff Raff in the SG-X I'd be tempted to try a Cold Sweat for a nice tight humbucker tone with some extra power.
BKPs I've Got:  RR, BKP-91, ITs, VHII, CS set, Emeralds
BKPs I Had:  RY+Abraxas, Crawlers, BD+SM

AndyR

Quote from: Philly Q on September 24, 2008, 10:35:59 PM
I find the BKP-91 great for clean sounds and gnarly old-school blues-rock tones (Leslie West!), but it lacks a humbucker's tight crunch for really distorted tones (Andy may disagree!  :wink: ). 

:lol:
I'm reaching the conclusion that what Philly calls "tight crunch" in this situation, and regards as desirable, I call "slight compression" and regard it as not that necesary for me, and sometimes not even desirable!

I think between the two of us, you might get the idea!! (or totally confused... :D)
Play or Download AndyR Music at [url="http://www.alonetone.com/andyr"]http://www.alonetone.com/andyr[/url]

Philly Q

Quote from: AndyR on September 25, 2008, 11:08:19 AM
I'm reaching the conclusion that what Philly calls "tight crunch" in this situation, and regards as desirable, I call "slight compression" and regard it as not that necesary for me, and sometimes not even desirable!

You're probably right - I've never been quite clear what people mean when they talk about a "compressed" sound.  I know what a compressor pedal does, but I have a bit of trouble relating that to pickup qualities.

The way I picture it is this:  a humbucker cancels hum and seems to also cancel (or rein in) certain frequencies and overtones so it sounds tighter, more focused.  A single-coil doesn't cancel anything so it sounds very open, with more overtones and dynamics, which (IMO) is great for clean sounds but not so great for distorted ones.  To me a distorted humbucker sounds "tidy" and a distorted single-coil/P-90 sounds "messy".

I know that's not a scientific explanation, in fact it's probably utter bollocks, but it's how I perceive things.  :oops:  :|
BKPs I've Got:  RR, BKP-91, ITs, VHII, CS set, Emeralds
BKPs I Had:  RY+Abraxas, Crawlers, BD+SM

Yamhammer

#6
It depends on what amp you're playing through.

Philly Q

Quote from: Yamhammer on September 25, 2008, 11:50:54 AM
By the way, BKP P90's don't sound messy by nature. They're very close to the BKP humbuckers in terms of output/power and with very low noise.

That's probably especially true of the MQ, since the metal cover provides some shielding.

(My BKP-91 still sounds pretty messy, to be honest, but that's OK, it does what I wanted it to  :) )
BKPs I've Got:  RR, BKP-91, ITs, VHII, CS set, Emeralds
BKPs I Had:  RY+Abraxas, Crawlers, BD+SM

Yamhammer

Yes, that story goes for the MQ's especially. I had to change some things (pedals) in my set-up to get it sound right too my ears, but after those few changes everything turned out great.

I've no experiences with the BKP P90's, so I can't comment on it!

AndyR

^ I'm agreeing with everything above :D

Philly - I picked up "compressed" on here a while back! My understanding of it in relation to a pickup is the "smoothing" or "tidying-up" that gives you that apparently tighter sound on the olde humbuckers.

Yamhammer and I were discussing it elsewhere the other day - I've found the P90 type MQ has a certain "hairyness" to it that I initially loved but then found somewhat intimidating for everyday use!

But then I remembered that they were actually single coils, so I started playing the guitar like I would a single-coiled strat: dig in with the pick when I want that tighter distorted sound (think SRV/Rory-type attack, not an elegant, light-touch picking technique!).

When I started doing that, it all started falling into place, and the MQ suddenly became very versatile for me... which is why, if all I had was a single pickup guitar, designed for a humbucker, I'd stick an MQ in it.
Play or Download AndyR Music at [url="http://www.alonetone.com/andyr"]http://www.alonetone.com/andyr[/url]

Yamhammer

#10
Quote from: AndyR on September 25, 2008, 12:40:13 PM
^ I'm agreeing with everything above :D

Philly - I picked up "compressed" on here a while back! My understanding of it in relation to a pickup is the "smoothing" or "tidying-up" that gives you that apparently tighter sound on the olde humbuckers.

Yamhammer and I were discussing it elsewhere the other day - I've found the P90 type MQ has a certain "hairyness" to it that I initially loved but then found somewhat intimidating for everyday use!

But then I remembered that they were actually single coils, so I started playing the guitar like I would a single-coiled strat: dig in with the pick when I want that tighter distorted sound (think SRV/Rory-type attack, not an elegant, light-touch picking technique!).

When I started doing that, it all started falling into place, and the MQ suddenly became very versatile for me... which is why, if all I had was a single pickup guitar, designed for a humbucker, I'd stick an MQ in it.

That's exactly what I did too.

gwEm

i really like the painkiller clean, i think it sounds great. i'd use this in a one pickup axe. not everyone enjoys the driven painkiller sound though. philking and will both criticised it :)
Quote from: AndyRyou wouldn't use the meat knife on crusty bread but, equally, the serrated knife and straight edge knife aren't going to go through raw meat as quickly

markofled

Im playing through a laney gh50l i play in a cover band that plays anything from Queens of the stone age through to Al Green. My sound is sightly overdriven and i use a Fuzz Factory for boosting My main guitar is a tele with brown sugars in. With the new guitar im not trying to achevive a specific tone im just looking for versatiliy although im probly leaning more towards the vintage side of things. This is the reason why i wonderd about Missippi queen, Mule and now im wondering about riff raffs?

Fikealox

Quote from: gwEm on September 25, 2008, 05:43:05 PM
i really like the painkiller clean, i think it sounds great. i'd use this in a one pickup axe. not everyone enjoys the driven painkiller sound though. philking and will both criticised it :)

I sort of agree, and sort of disagree. I like the Painkiller clean for melodic stuff, but for chords I find it a bit too compressed and hot. That said, I think it's a great pickup, and I totally love mine (even though I'm having trouble EQing the top two strings with it).
BKPs (soon): CS, TS.
Ex-BKPs: Abrax, NB, SM, PK, Mule, WP.

ilÿti

For a one-hum guitar, I'd take the approach that I'd want something that could do the parts I normally play on the neck pickup, without sounding too shrill. Holy Diver for me.
Crawlers, Mule-7s
The Danish parliament is working on an official apology for Lars Ulrich