ello ello chaps.
Indeed I did buy the blue Burny LP custom from Japanguitars, and (as Philly said) I was ecstatic with the guitar. (still am).
But yeah his description was a bit silly. Mint condition it certainly was not. (not that it bothers me much- just seems a bit silly to claim something like that when it obviously isn't).
I'm pretty sure whatever you get you'll love. These MIJ LPs have gained such a good reputation.
There's always 'Signatures' that Dakine/Nick brought up a while ago. Really love the look of them. Usually come up on ebay from time to time, and there is one shop that sells them retail (only 1 or 2 finishes though).
Basically, Burny, Tokai, Edwards, Orville; all will do the job. I chose mine purely on the fact that I loved the Blue finish, am a fan of Jerry Cantrell, and wanted something a bit different.
Different people will give you different opinions on which out of the lot of them is 'the best', (I tried asking around). Remember; it also depends a lot on the actual time period they are from (if you're going for old ones).
Anyway, good luck, hope you get something you like; I'm off to school for double-history now. YAWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWN.
p.s. I'll try and find that shop that sells the Signatures- I think they look VERY nice, and remember Nick absolutely loving his.
EDIT:
http://www.guitarbitz.com/602.htmNick's thread (scroll down and see a picture of his own one):
http://bareknucklepickups.co.uk/forum/viewtopic.php?t=5295&highlight=signature+les+paul