• Welcome to Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum.
 

set of SM + ?? for a 3 PU LesPaul Custom

Started by sushi, March 07, 2008, 09:38:47 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

sushi

Hello

I have a 3 PU Gibson LesPaul Artisan (like Custom). I already installed 2 stormy monday in bridge and neck position. I really love the sound of the neck pickup ( clean sound  is wonderfull !!). I want to put the bridge Stormy Monday in middle position and buy a new Mule to put on bridge position. I think an ALNICO II Mule should be better than a ALNICO IV Mule if I want a sweet clean sound (and some time, make it scream !).
Is it a good solution ?
Any advice ?

Thanks

Charles
"shadrach Meshack Abednego"

Fourth Feline

Hi Charles,  :D

Having tried both SMs and Mules in my Les Paul Standard, I can confirm that the 'standard' AIV Mule is also sweet sounding - albeit with a bit more clean 'push' if you need it - notably with more midrange than the SM. It is still not compressed though, so you will get that lovely open sound from both.

Both are lovely pickups - and if you play a lot of clean ( like I do ) both work nicely. I gather the 'Mule' is closer to the original sound of a late 50s PAF - and the SM an early 60s.

It must be lovely to have a Les Paul with both types in together,  especially using the combination of pickup positions you are considering !   8)

Catalyst77

I was thinking about putting a SM in my 3 pickup LP custom; what does it sound like?

Are they really versatile?
HUM: RR, M, SM, VH2, EM, BD,CS, CR, HD, NB, WP, RY, SINGLE :IT, SH, p90: MQ

sushi

Quote from: Fourth FelineHi Charles,  :D

Having tried both SMs and Mules in my Les Paul Standard, I can confirm that the 'standard' AIV Mule is also sweet sounding - albeit with a bit more clean 'push' if you need it - notably with more midrange than the SM. It is still not compressed though, so you will get that lovely open sound from both.

Both are lovely pickups - and if you play a lot of clean ( like I do ) both work nicely. I gather the 'Mule' is closer to the original sound of a late 50s PAF - and the SM an early 60s.

It must be lovely to have a Les Paul with both types in together,  especially using the combination of pickup positions you are considering !   8)

I used to play a standard LesPaul with a pair of Mule Alnico IV, the sound was louder (with mid) and it is a pleasure to play it "Rock". But the Lespaul artisan is totally different (acousticaly !) and the fretboard is ebony with wide and low frets, so I play differently ! Yesterday, I compare both guitars on a Marshall JTM45 Reissue, and the LP std was very "mid range" and had some crunch. But the LP Artisan was very clean, the neck PU was jazz/funk and the bridge was bright but not loud enough to crunch.
So, if I want the same bridge sound with more level output, should I choose a Stormy monday Alnico IV or a Mule Anico II ?

ps: excuse my english, I'm french ...
"shadrach Meshack Abednego"

sushi

Quote from: Benmartin1977I was thinking about putting a SM in my 3 pickup LP custom; what does it sound like?

Are they really versatile?

Yes !
I will post some MP3 later.
But you can watch this video (it's me...):
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PuavPedirvA

charles
"shadrach Meshack Abednego"

Twinfan

I think I'd email Tim and see what he says.

The Mule has a different 'voice' to an SM, so it's not just a louder version of the same thing.  Same goes for an AIV SM rather than an AII SM.

If it was me, I think I'd try an AII Mule.

sushi

Quote from: TwinfanI think I'd email Tim and see what he says.

The Mule has a different 'voice' to an SM, so it's not just a louder version of the same thing.  Same goes for an AIV SM rather than an AII SM.

If it was me, I think I'd try an AII Mule.

I agree with you, SM and Mule have different 'voice'.
Do you think the Mule AII is brighter than Mule AIV ? Does the mule AII is "like" an SM AII but louder ?
"shadrach Meshack Abednego"

PhilKing

Tim has told me in the past that he doesn't like the sound of AII and AIV together.  If you are wanting more push from the bridge with a brightish sound, then I would check out the AV Mule.  I have a set with the AV Mule and AIV Stormy Monday coming for my Zemaitis Pearl Front (clone!).
So many pickups, so little time

sushi

Quote from: PhilKingTim has told me in the past that he doesn't like the sound of AII and AIV together.  If you are wanting more push from the bridge with a brightish sound, then I would check out the AV Mule.  I have a set with the AV Mule and AIV Stormy Monday coming for my Zemaitis Pearl Front (clone!).

I didn't indicate before that my set of Stormy Monday is Alnico II !
Maybe I should choose a Mule Alnico II for the bridge... it will be good with SM Alnico II in neck and middle !
"shadrach Meshack Abednego"

PhilKing

So many pickups, so little time

sushi

Does Mule Alnico V have a great clean sound ?
what's the difference between Mule AIV and AV ?

And what about the PG Blues ?
"shadrach Meshack Abednego"

gwEm

Quote from: sushiDoes Mule Alnico V have a great clean sound ?
what's the difference between Mule AIV and AV ?

And what about the PG Blues ?

A5 vs A4 mule:

A5 has more bite and is a little more modern/transparent. It has a great clean tone, and works really well with a A4 neck (and i imagine A2). Of course the A5 version is a little hotter, but not by too much.

I wrote a comparative post of A4 vs A5 mule a while ago, have a quick search for it.

I agree with Phil and Tim that A4/A2 mix doesn't work that well. i mean - its not bad - totally usuable, but A5/A4 is better. Can't speak for A5/A2
Quote from: AndyRyou wouldn't use the meat knife on crusty bread but, equally, the serrated knife and straight edge knife aren't going to go through raw meat as quickly

Twinfan

Quote from: sushiI agree with you, SM and Mule have different 'voice'.
Do you think the Mule AII is brighter than Mule AIV ? Does the mule AII is "like" an SM AII but louder ?

I would think a Mule AII is no nrighter than a Mule AIV, it'll just sound a bit "softer".

sushi

Quote from: PhilKingYou could still get AV with AII.

A bridge riff raff AV ? for example ?
"shadrach Meshack Abednego"

PhilKing

[quote="sushi]A bridge riff raff AV ? for example ?[/quote]

Always a great combination!
So many pickups, so little time