I haven't voted, but the question I would ask is: do you enjoy playing it, or do you always pick up something else ahead of it? IMHO there's no point keeping a guitar you don't like playing - it's just taking up space that could be occupied by something you like.
In my experience, the gut is usually right about these things. I bought an Ibanez RG470 about 7 years ago, because it was what I thought I wanted, but I was never sure about it. Sold it a year later, having played it for maybe 4 hours at the most. Like I said, the gut is seldom wrong.