Right, some bad news about the amp. The Mullard El34's (well at least one of them), are duff. They cause crackle when you prod the amp. With a known good set of JJ's put in, I could not replicate the crackle however hard I hit the amp. Put the Mullards back in and the crackle was instantly easily produced.
Also, the more I play it, the more I believe that something is just not right with the amp. I really should like the tone, and I don't, It's truly harsh and horrible. I have been through a lot of amps, and read a lot of opinions, and listened to a lot of soundclips to get to the point of buying this amp. I also have a very similar amp, the 1987, which I just love. I cannot believe that this is what a proper functioning 2204 sounds like. Also, there's nowhere near as much gain as I thought a 2204 should have. Also, the amp is definately noisier than I would like
It's not the tubes, I have replaced all of them with known good tubes - nothing changes.
I wouldn't be happy to sell the amp in this state, unless it was a "sold as seen". For someone who knows amps and amp repairs it might be a great buy.
I think my main option is to get a good tech to install some new EL34's, bias it up correctly, and then spend some time troubleshooting the amp. It could be something as simple as just needing a cap job. The amp is 30 years old after all. At least then I'll find out what this amp is capable of. And if I still don't like it, I can sell it with a clear conscience knowing that it was all sorted.
Great - another money pit - just what I need right at the moment.