Quote
I can't help but think that they are attempting to sell politics... do they really think that meaningful political change will come by empowering 14-year-olds who couldn't have the slightest idea about politics to overthrow the government? Let's be realistic, that would TOTALLY $%&# up the world. The political message really seems like more of a selling point to appeal to teen angst. Which I disagree with.
It seems to me you are placing too much emphasis on the lyrics and meaning of the songs. Who cares if RATM don't really have a clue about the intricacies of government and politics- it's not like they're running for office or anything! I think their appeal is more to do with the incessant screaming and loud music. :D Sometimes nothing beats a good angry protest song, you know?

Quote
I also can't really see what's so great about Morello's riffs either... they seem a little derivative and pretty rarely ever break away from a pentatonic scale. And I would argue that his solos, infact, ARE wanky (see Know Your Enemy)
But yes, their lyrics are truly amazing. Brilliantly thought out with a superb and poignant political message. Here is a superb example:
I wouldn't say his riffs are in any way derivative- they have a pretty distinguishable sound in fact. And the fact that he sticks to the pentatonic seems a pretty meaningless issue to me- if it sounds good I don't care how basic it is!
We may have to just disagree on the solos, as I don't think his are anyway near the likes of the popular shredders out there. Mostly, (including Know Your Enemy) they are catchy, memorable and interesting (to me, anyway!) :)
And some of the lyrics ARE pretty good, but everyone likes a bit of mindless swearing every now and then. :D