• Welcome to Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum.
 

rant on certain sounding hendrix tributes...

Started by gwEm, August 08, 2008, 12:30:22 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

gwEm

hendrix is messy, noisy, passionate, groovy and agressively improvised! DAMN!

how i dislike these oh so very clean and nice hendrix tribute cover versions!  :twisted: :evil: :shock:
Quote from: AndyRyou wouldn't use the meat knife on crusty bread but, equally, the serrated knife and straight edge knife aren't going to go through raw meat as quickly

kellar

I agree with you gwEm. Nobody does Hendrix quite like he did. Hendrix was very unconventional in his approach to the guitar, and that is what makes him incredibly unique (and nearly impossible to duplicate). Although, I always thought that Stevie Ray Vaughan could do Hendrix like no other.
Calibrated IV Mules, Stormy Monday/Riff Raff

indysmith

Quote from: kellar on August 08, 2008, 01:48:11 PM
I always thought that Stevie Ray Vaughan could do Hendrix like no other.
I like SRV's covers of Hendrix too, but they don't sound like Hendrix, they sound like Stevie-Ray and I like that :P

I'd imagine a lot of the people covering Hendrix are not simply trying to copy him (that would be pointless), but impart their own style on his music. Their style is probably just less incredible than his, which is not surprising!
But yeah I agree; Hendrix tunes sound best rough'n'raw.
[size=9px]LOVING the Mules![/size]

headtheball

Y'know who could probably do Hendrix-type stuff justice?

Jack White. He's got the "messy, noisy, passionate, groovy and agressively improvised" thing down pat.
Evil, Evil, Evil...

MrBump

I think that the key to Hendrix was his rhythm section.  Like Cream, it was the tight and progressive drums and bass that allowed for all that wonderful guitarness.
BKPs Past and Present - Nailbombs, Mules, Blackguard Flat 50's, VHII's & Trilogy Suite with Neck & Bridge Baseplates!

Elliot

Mitch Mitchell = the groovey god of drummers

BKPS: Milks, P90s, Apaches, Mississippi Queens, Mules, PG Blues, BG FP 50s, e.60s strat custom set

ilÿti

I think the problem is when they try to sound like Hendrix and fail. In my opinion the best covers are by people who just throw caution to the wind and go for it, playing the song in their own styles. I love Vai's version of Little Wing, but for completely different reasons than what I love the original version for. I also love Shawn Lane's Hendrix covers.
Crawlers, Mule-7s
The Danish parliament is working on an official apology for Lars Ulrich

WezV

i hate it when i here some bland cover of angel or something like that... the jimi version is something i would happily play at my funeral - especially the solo jimi in home studio version

anybody else and it just sounds really commercial and really over sung
[url=http://www.wezvenables.co.uk]www.wezvenables.co.uk[/url]

38thBeatle

Oversung? Blimey I didn't know Mariah Carey did a version of it
Send three and fourpence we're going to a dance
BKP's: Apache, Country Boy, Slowhands.

WezV

she probably did... there have been a few time when i have heard the melody and started humming only to be violently insulted by a x factor style vocal performance
[url=http://www.wezvenables.co.uk]www.wezvenables.co.uk[/url]

headtheball

Let's not forget the nation-shaming horror that was the Corrs covering Little Wing. Like being drowned in syrup.
Evil, Evil, Evil...

horsehead

But to be fair to the Corrs at least it was different from the Hendrix version...I like it

----------------
Now playing: Prince - 7
via FoxyTunes
"Praising Phil X for his enthusiasm seems a bit like praising Hitler for his ambition"

MrBump

Just YouTubed The Corrs and Little Wing.

I actually like it too.

Maybe I'm getting old...
BKPs Past and Present - Nailbombs, Mules, Blackguard Flat 50's, VHII's & Trilogy Suite with Neck & Bridge Baseplates!

Philly Q

Randy Hansen is one of the best known Hendrix tribute guys and I think he gets the feel pretty much exactly right, but throws in his own improv stuff so he's not just an impersonator.

Not talking about Hendrix covers exactly, but some great players like Ulrich Roth and Frank Marino have made fantastic Hendrix-influenced music.  And of course Robin Trower!!  He gets branded a Hendrix clone - and he's never denied the influence for a second - but he takes that sound and takes it somewhere else, making it somehow very "English".  There's no-one better.


BKPs I've Got:  RR, BKP-91, ITs, VHII, CS set, Emeralds
BKPs I Had:  RY+Abraxas, Crawlers, BD+SM

_tom_

This is why John Mayers Bold As Love cover is only meh at best.
[url=http://soundcloud.com/shotgunroyale[Shotgun Royale[/url]