• Welcome to Bare Knuckle Pickups Forum.
 

Satch sues Coldplay!!!

Started by Sifu Ben, December 05, 2008, 12:01:40 PM

Previous topic - Next topic

Sifu Ben

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/7766683.stm
When I first read this I thought they were taking the p*ss, but now I've listened to them back to back I think he may have something.....
Cold Sweat, Nailbomb 7b, Cold Sweat 7n

Groove Cartel

And so he should.... I picked this up when I first heard the track.

Shame they can't also be sued for the release of lifeless, dull, middle class cr@p.....
[url="//www.groovecartel.co.uk"]www.groovecartel.co.uk[/url]
www.vanquishguitars.co.uk

headtheball

Surely, though, Coldplay can sue Athlete, Snow Patrol, and so on, ad nauseum, to get the money to pay Satch?
Evil, Evil, Evil...

Crazy_Joe

#3
As much as i think Coldplay suck, it sounds like a coincidence more than a direct rip off of Joe's song.

At the end of the day, both are very simple chord progs and anyone could make them, it's not like they actually took a guitar riff.
Black Dogs

Previous BKP's: Riff Raff, Holy Divers, Painkillers, C. Warpig, Nailbomb, Miracle Man.

Sifu Ben

Ahh, but what's interesting here is not about chord progressions and riffs, it's about the similarity of the melodic guitar line of one and the vocal melody of the other.
I think proving exposure could be tricky though, unless there's a magazine article somewhere where they say that they really like Satriani (pretty unlikely)
Cold Sweat, Nailbomb 7b, Cold Sweat 7n

Crazy_Joe

I can't see Satch getting anything. But I see the similarity.
Black Dogs

Previous BKP's: Riff Raff, Holy Divers, Painkillers, C. Warpig, Nailbomb, Miracle Man.

sgmypod

Autotune My Arse

Crawler,nailbomb & Ltd Ed Emeralds, apache, now riff raff..EX- N/bomb, IT, Mquee

sgmypod

Autotune My Arse

Crawler,nailbomb & Ltd Ed Emeralds, apache, now riff raff..EX- N/bomb, IT, Mquee

Jonny

"Would you like some lemon oil?"
"Oh, no thanks, I don't eat fruit."

Crazy_Joe

Quote from: sgmypod on December 05, 2008, 01:52:38 PM
You tube comparisonhttp://uk.youtube.com/watch?v=1ofFw9DKu_I&feature=related

Haha, listening to that i think he has more of a case now. I still don't think he will get anything though. He is saying he is seeking damages and "any and all profits". That's not going to happen.
Black Dogs

Previous BKP's: Riff Raff, Holy Divers, Painkillers, C. Warpig, Nailbomb, Miracle Man.

Jonny

Damage by plagarism. But still.. however it's worded I still think he has a chance.
"Would you like some lemon oil?"
"Oh, no thanks, I don't eat fruit."

Antag

Stupid move by Satch IMO.  Nothing good will come of it - it will be a PR disaster & he'll gain no money (in fact he'll probably make a net loss after lawyers fees etc)
BKPs: HD, MM, NB, PK, CS, Ab (b&n); Am (b only); VHII, Tril (n only); IT, Slow, Sult (m&n)

Johnny Mac

If it is a coincidence its a bit freaky or perhaps Joe wants a go on the singers missus, I would.
Warpig, MQ,
Miracle Man-Trilogy Suite, Cold Sweats, Black Guards, Rebel Yells & Irish Tours!

mecca777

I'm certain I read an interview with Satriani many years back where he talked about the plethora of TV commercials and soundtrack work that sounded curiously reminiscent of some of his famous tracks; his (paraphrased) attitude was that it was galling, but that there was no really sensible way of pursuing people who did it because it's unreasonable to expect the legal profession to pick up on the subtleties that are obvious to musicians. Nice to see he's becoming more litigious as the years roll on and the follicles evaporate. :)

I suspect he's on a hiding to nothing with this one. I do seem to remember Oasis getting hammered with some sort of plagiarism case back in the days when they were relevant, but I think there was a lyrical similarity to the source (Stevie Wonder?) as well. And of course the Rubinoos recently had a crack at Avril Lavigne*, but they were doomed from the start because "I Wanna Be Your Boyfriend" is a carbon-copy of "Get Off My Cloud" anyway.

* bonus points if you could read that sentence without interjecting "I JUST BET THEY DID" in a seedy voice

WezV

who knows if its a coincidence or not... but is it also coincidence that coldplay where nominated for 7 grammys yesterday!!  No fuss about this when it came out and i cant believe that neither satch or any or his people were aware of it so why wait till now to bring it up???

At the end of the day its about PR and thats all.

it seems strange to me that you would copy a song so closely... if i was purposely copying something i would at least change enough to avoid legal problems.  That makes me think it must be coincidence

btw, i am no coldplay fan, lets make that clear
[url=http://www.wezvenables.co.uk]www.wezvenables.co.uk[/url]