I never really liked Kerrang much back in the day and when metal took a nose-dive in popularity around '94 it got worse - all you got was all that post-punk cr@p (Fat Wreck Chords anyone?).
Metal Hammer was my mag of choice back in the late 80s/early 90s, as was 'Raw' and occasionally 'Hit Parade' had some decent stuff in.
All I buy now is Terroriser (actually I subscribe, but same thing). Their reviews are right on the money and I find that their 8/10 (or more) reviewed albums are typcially very, very good - I've got into bands on the strength of their reviews and am rarely dissappointed.
case in point, a band called 'Trap Them' were on their cover-mounted CD and I've since tracked down some of their stuff which I'm really digging.