Its just unproffesional, IMO.
I mean Tim keeps on top of mountains of inquires, >200 emails a day, and still makes shiteeeeloads of pickups.
I've only dealt with Bob Johnson for extended periods, and his customer service is also exemplary, deals with a similar rate of email enquiry and he also makes superb guitars with passion and dedication, so guitars-are-a-bigger-job isnt really an excuse, I think.
Not that you need an excuse to not be in the elite, but just not replying to emails, especially for such a high value item, is below par, no matter what your idosyncracies.
I'm sure the guitars are superb and hes a great guy, but open communication avenues and ease of getting in contact are huge parts of dealing with custom stuff. He aint replying -> he aint getting that custom -> those people mention it on the internet -> people make their call whether they want to deal with that -> invariably loses more custom.
I'm guessing he's not in it to expand his customer base, but, regardless of my opnion (which averages to neutral or so - he seems alright and I'm willing to give the benefit of the doubt that you can talk out a guitar with him in sufficient detail on the phone), its going to diminish his reputation, when everyones taken into account. Its not terribly wise.
In summary - He should answer his emails!
he cares about building his guitars, he should act like he cares about people wanting them - youre going after a 2k guitar, and its a big deal to you. I'm not saying eh doesnt all told, but not replying to emails makes it look that way if a no-reply is the only info you get, and you have no access to 'the loop' to learn his quirks.