and it was a holy diver, right? :shock:
i'm not discussing if amps react different to boosters
that's obvious
what i'm talking about is how the holy diver changes, no matter what amp
peaveys and engls are way less responsive to boosters, but they do change the tone, specially if the pickup is not really hot or tight by itself
he said that the pickup didn't sound as tight as he wanted through that specific amp and others did
so if he didn't try a booster with THAT pickup in that same amp, he can't assume that it won't make any difference because "powerballs are tight and boosters do nothing for them"
some common combinations may sound like shiteeeee, while others not-that-logical combinations can be great (like a miracle man on maple body or mid heavy 5150s through ultra middy heavy speakers)
but you can't make solid assumptions without trying it in at least close situations
I always thought that a holy diver would be the greatest thing in an SG (I should have listened to our Master), and it didn't sound good
sounded weak and muffled and dark
and it didn't make any sense to me, since I had it in two fat les pauls, and one of them had exactly the same wood grain/resonance/voicing/tone of the SG and was a way fatter and darker sounding guitar (plus a imbuya top that darkens everything a lot), and the diver sounded AWESOME in that les paul
maybe the extra wood "pushed" the pickup harder or something
I never could understand that, but that's a fact
if Tim says that something might not work well, is not because he can calculate all the factors and results, but because he obviously tried it before
it's like someone wrote some kind of gospel on guitar forums and most people just repeat stuff like "VHT and Mesa Mark amps are tighter than anything" and "Bogners are built like a tank and Framus are built like shiteeee with cheap parts", "Diezels are tight and hi fi", "Triple XXXs are not even close to the JSX", "death magnetic tone is great cause its got Diezels and Diezels are awesome and I can get exactly the some tone through mine", and "Marshalls can't do metal" without any kind of related experience
and when they actually try them, they have their minds already so made up, that their ears stop working or something
here in brazil, for example, it's hard to convince anyone that there are better amps than Rectos, even if you prove it to them, cause they think that a "Mesa is a Mesa" and nothing can be better than that
lol gotta work, c ya