What is the warmest, natural overdrive pedal around in peoples opinion?
When people use words like
warm, I cringe a bit, because to me "warm" can also be euphonic. What sounds nice and laid back to one person may be too soft and tubby for another. In contrast, a clean, dyanamic pedal to one person might be too edgy and flat to another.
I think that overall the HBE would be too clean for what you're looking for. Try before you buy that one.
Euphonic pedals always seem to get in the way, to my ears, but there are a few really good pedals out there. In no particular order:
The
Reezafratzis (spelling, Brow?) is very warm, lush and euphonic.
The
Fulltone Full-Drive II is a great sounding overdrive with a mid peak and built-in compression.
The
Klon Centaur is a great, warm OD.
No offense, but stay away from the Tube Screamer, Boss ODs and the like if you can afford to. I think they sound terrible. (Please don't flame me for this!!)