Colour can be very good, but its also unpredictable.
But a lot of the time people want reassurance that the effect or whatever is going to do its job without any other unanticipated effects on the sound.
For example, I use 2 EQs in my FX loop - an MXR 10 band, which is very transparent, and its what I do all the actual EQing with, and a Boss EQ20, which is a far cry from transparent, but I very much like the effect it has on the sound, and I run it flat for its un-transparency/colour.