Not to branch off too wildly from the congratulatory session but would it cost more to get a non-relic'd guitar relic'd or just to buy one of these?
I'm not really sure.
To be honest, if they did a Roadworn NOS, I'd be buying those instead :lol:
I think the main thing is that you'd want "nitro finished" to get "authentic" looking relicing. Witness this very guitar actually - the bodies are nitro finish, but the necks are the standard MIM necks sanded down - so poly. That's why the maple board guitars have dodgy looking maple boards!
I have seen pictures of people making SRV copies out of Squiers etc - but you'll always be open to "that's a fine job, but you can't really relic poly properly, can you..."
It seems to me that "decent" relicing is quite an art form and somewhat time consuming - so rather expensive (unless you do it yourself, and that could possibly prove even more expensive!!). I'm guessing that if someone's after relic fenders, then the Roadworns are the possibly the best bang-for-buck at the moment. For me that includes the Custom Shop option and the guys who turn out relics for a living. It all depends whether you'd be comfortable with the relicing on the guitar itself - but that actually applies to all of them, even the most and bespoke expensive ones, not just the poor old Roadworns and their regimented wear... (actually, now I have two, it's not that regimented - you can see that there must be instructions in the factory "a bit here, two or three bits there..." and so on - but you'd actually have to be going out of your way to notice the pattern on these two. It's only cos you know they're mass produced that you start looking for and noticing holes in roughly the same place... I'm more than comfy having the two sat next to each other in the living room, I wasn't sure I would be...)
BUT - I'm not really a relic-guy. I'm not anti them at all (well, I wouldn't have these two would I? :lol:), but I don't get excited by relics, and definitely wouldn't spend big bucks on one myself at the moment. I tried the Roadworns because I heard they can be crazy-good guitars, worth the 100 or so more than the standard MIMs (which I'd tried, and didn't really like). The Roadworn's I've played have been stunners, they just talk to me, and I managed to get over the look and the "reliced to a pattern" thing about them.... so they found themselves coming home with me :)
EDIT: Another thing to bear in mind if you try them out - all the roadworns I've seen in shops, including the two I've bought, really do look and feel thoroughly neglected and unloved. That changes within hours of getting the thing home and starting to, er, love it :lol:. After just a couple of weeks playing and polishing with a dry cloth, my 60s one started looking like a million dollars... and I'm sure this one will too