Interesting how many folks are saying "Explorer". If I hadn't bought one a few years back, that's exactly what I'd have been saying too. I lusted after that shape for, ooh, must be nearly 30 years... (hardly ever touch the thing, of course... :roll:, but I'm soo glad I have it...)
I have a guitar that I kinda "like" but have never played that much - a V.
I'm determined not to give in to V-lust though, it was always the Explorer for me. Thinking about getting a V really is a "hmmm... seem to have everything I wanted :?, what else can I GAS over now??!"
Of guitars I have actually played but didn't buy:
A Gibson Les Paul (that I didn't buy on the day I bought the Explorer) - that was just creamy yummy... but a sizable amount more than I've ever spent on a guitar. I've since acquired a lovely Japanese Love Rock at less than half the price this gibbo was, but it's not quite as nice as I remember that gibbo... funnily enough, all other Les Pauls I've ever tried have always left me wondering what the fuss was really about, but that one was rather nice...
A Fender Roadworn 50s tele (blonde, obviously). I've played a couple and they do kinda kick the teles I own into a c--ked-hat... but I'm rather fond of the teles I own, none of them are leaving, and I can't really justify another at the moment (especially as I seem to have acquired two Roadworn strats while my mind was wandering aimlessly...)